Tim O’Brien’s “The Things They Carried” Discussion Research

Tim O’Brien’s “The important things They Brought” Conversation Research

The Important Things They Carried– Discussion Research 1. “A thing may happen and be a total lie; another thing might not take place and be truer than the truth.” In his stories, Tim plays with the reality. He has actually been doing this considering that he was a young kid, wishing his girlfriend back to life. He understands that if you try hard enough and are creative enough, you can bring the dead back to life in stories. It doesn’t matter whether the stories are exactly true– you can alter the name, or location, or even parts of what occurs– the sensation of truth will still exist.

This is possibly the essence of what Tim calls “story-truth”– not truths, but genuine sensations and impressions.– www. Bookrags. com 2. “A thing may occur and be an overall lie; another thing might not take place and be truer than the reality.” O’Brien’s novel is its deliberately confusing blurring of truth and fiction. The novel is subtitled “a work of fiction,” and its copyright page disclaims, “This is a work of fiction. Except for a few information relating to the author’s own life, all the occurrences, names, and characters are imaginary.”– www. radesaver. com 3. “They moved like mules. By daylight they took sniper fire, in the evening they were mortared, but it was not battle, it was simply the unlimited march, village to village, without purpose, absolutely nothing won or lost. They marched for the sake of the march.” (Page 15) Commentary: This quote, coming early in the book, explains how the Vietnam War was different from WWII. Instead of taking part in open fight with an unique front, Vietnam was more about search and destroy. Finding the enemy was more difficult than killing him.

The unlimited dullness of the march denies the soldiers from feeling as though they’ve achieved anything– no battles won or lost. This increases the sense of obscurity in the war and in the book. The unique makes strategic shifts backward and forward in between very first and 3rd individual. The very first chapter is entirely 3rd individual, preparing for the themes of the book with generalizations and insights. By the 2nd chapter O’Brien moves to very first person, placing a version of himself as a character, as he talks about the war with his former commander.

He continues to change back and forth in between the 2 voices throughout the unique, producing an interesting effect. A new theme frequently starts with a couple of pages of musings and memories, composed in 3rd person, which is instantly followed by a first-person story that supplies examples of the very same theme. Hence, we have a fluid transition from general to specific. Within the first individual narrative there are also major transitions in time. Most stories include O’Brien as a young soldier, told in real time as if he’s back in Vietnam. He describes the sights, sounds, and his emotion as if he’s still in his early twenties.

Later on in the chapter, nevertheless, he will leap ahead twenty years and share his sensations and impressions of the very same incident. The Male I Eliminated is the best example of this time warp.– www. thebestnotes. com 5. “Kiowa, a devout Baptist, Carried a detailed New Testimony that had been presented to him by his daddy, who taught Sunday school in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma.” “Kiowa constantly brought his New Testament and a set of moccasins for silence.” Kiowa is the emotional compass of Alpha Company, the one who gets everyone else to talk.

Kiowa tries to comfort “O’Brien” after he kills the North Vietnamese soldier, and it is to Kiowa that Dobbins opens about his regard for the clergy. The night prior to Kiowa is eliminated, the young soldier remains in a tent speaking to him about his sweetheart left. Kiowa helps “O’Brien” by easing his shifts. He makes “O’Brien” more comfortable when he gets to the war, talking to him about the others’ jokes about corpses, and he attempts to get “O’Brien” to discuss the Vietnamese soldier he eliminated. “O’Brien” tells the story of Linda to Kiowa.

It is from Kiowa, for that reason, that “O’Brien” discovers the importance of interacting, leading eventually to his becoming a writer. In some methods, Kiowa’s death is what makes “O’Brien” a writer, a teller of stories. When he returns to Vietnam with Katherine, he takes her to the site of Kiowa’s death in the field. Although “O’Brien” does not inform her the story of Kiowa, he brings her to that site so that he may pass the story on, simply as he will hand down the story of how he eliminated a guy when he feels Katherine is ready to hear it.– www. cliffsnotes. com 6. They carried all they could bear, and then some, consisting of a silent awe for the dreadful power of the important things they carried. ” The storyteller notes things that the soldiers bring with them, both tangible and intangible, such as Lt. Cross’s image of and feelings for Martha. Other members of the system are presented through descriptions of the things they carry, such as Henry Dobbins who brings additional food, Ted Lavender who brings tranquilizer pills, and Kiowa who brings a hunting hatchet. O’Brien introduces readers to the book’s main characters by explaining the posts that the soldiers carry.

The level of detail O’Brien offers about the characters is broadened upon and lit up in the chapters that follow, though O’Brien distills the essence of each characters’ personality through the symbolic items each carries.– www. cliffsnotes. com 7. “Mary Anne made you think of all those girls back home, how clean and innocent they are, how they’ll never ever comprehend any of this, not in a billion years. Try to inform them about it, they’ll just look at you with those huge round sweet eyes. They won’t comprehend zip. It’s like trying to tell someone what chocolate tastes like. (Page 113) Commentary: Rat Kiley discussing the sense of isolation soldiers feel from their peers back in the United States. While good friends are working at junk food dining establishment of going to college, these kids are killing individuals and blowing things up. They have little in typical with former good friends when they return. www. thebestnotes. com 8. “My conscience told me to run, however some illogical and effective force was withstanding, like a weight pressing me toward the war. What it boiled down to, stupidly, was a sense of pity.” Chapter 4, pg. 52 Pity is the reason that Tim O’Brien chose to go to Vietnam.

Much of the characters feel shame as a primary incentive, too. Not only does it lead them to war, but it keeps them there. It is the one thing that keeps them from shooting themselves in the foot so that they would be discharged from the army or some similar such act. But some characters, like Curt Lemon, think that pity urges them to heroism, not stupidity.– www. gradesaver. com 9. No direct quote In the case of Tim O’brien, who is a fiction author but has actually done some non-fiction, the inspiration for his writing is fairly simple to area.

O’Brien is best known for his fictional accounts of the Vietnam war in the book, The Things They Brought, and he confesses himself that reason he composed the things that he did was merely because” [he] desires you to feel what [he] felt” (Webster 8). Tim is a Vietnam veterinarian. 10. No direct quote There were 3 types of ladies in The Important Things They Carried. These functions of females, showed in Martha, Linda and Kathleen, were love, death, and an enabler. The following explanation specifies their function in the novel and the impact they made. Martha is Lt.

Jimmy Cross’s love, although she has only considers him as a good friend. O’Brien’s uses their story to show a typical trend between soldiers and the separation created by the war. Twenty years after the war or when it ended, soldiers returned house attempting to renew the lives they left for the war. As seen in the relationship between Cross and Martha, it wasn’t as wished for. Faced with death in Vietnam, Cross declines to believe Martha isn’t a virgin and a life shared in between the 2 was possible. This was a safe, comforting idea contrary to among rejection and possible death during war.

Throughout his time in Vietnam, Cross is obsessed with Martha resulting in Ted Lavender’s death. He burns her letters and images as an attempt to reconcile his regret; however, it’s at that later conference where he receives a new photograph of her, that the full-fledged guilt impact is felt as she rejects his advances due to the fact that she was never thinking about him. Linda is Tim O’Brien’s youth “love”. She passes away at the age of 9 due to a brain growth. Her function is to give O’Brien a reason to compose stories: to commemorate the dead.

Those who die can be revitalized through storytelling. Linda is the prime example of O’Brien’s belief that storytelling help the healing procedure of discomfort, confusion, and unhappiness that features an unforeseen death. After she dies, he uses his imagination to bring her back to life, illustrating that the dead can still be alive through literature. His experience with Linda’s death discusses why he handled death so well in Vietnam. Even though Norman Bowker and Kiowa pass away unexpectedly, they are both brought back to life in O’Brien’s stories like Linda.

Their lives and how they lived are more important than their deaths. O’Brien’s storytelling also keeps his sanity undamaged and they dead aren’t truly gone. Kathleen is O’Brien’s daughter. She’s the enabler for O’Brien’s stories that “aren’t real”. Like the reader, Kathleen is finding out O’Brien’s war stories; however, she has the ability to question O’Brien and open his mind. An example of her capability is seen when he reviews Vietnam. O’Brien has a various perspective of his experiences when he thinks about how he needs to tell the story of the man he killed to his 8 year old daughter.

It’s simpler for the reader to neglect and under appreciate the description O’Brien gives up his stories compared to how little he tells his daughter. When O’Brien takes her to Vietnam, she does not comprehend what he went through as the odor and the exoticness of the land are the only think that strike her. Contrary to the reader, she likewise does not understand about the field and its significance to O’Brien as his “swim” strikes her as odd. The 3 functions of females in the story are ignored as the tale of Mary Anne Bell, a woman who turns into one with the land; eclipse the other girls’ significance.

Although Mary Anne Bell’s story shows how ladies need to have been deemed equal during the war as they might hold their own, the novel was more about war and the results related to it than equality of the sexes. 11. No direct quote The emotional immaturity of the GI’s in Vietnam makes it vital that they find methods to manage the killing of enemies and the passing away of friends. O’Brien writes, “They utilized a tough vocabulary to contain the dreadful softness.” (Page 20) The soldiers within a platoon formed intimate relationships, however when death occurred language assisted trivialize those bonds to make the separation less uncomfortable.

They utilized words like greased, zapped, offed, illuminated, to explain the deaths of their pals. When Ted Lavender died, the soldiers in his squadron talked as if it were the tranquilizers that had actually killed him– blew his mind. They way they described it in the stories he didn’t feel a thing. O’Brien keeps in mind how, earlier in his life when Linda had actually died, Nick Vorheen had described it as ‘kicking the bucket’. Language is a coping system, a way of making things less agonizing, or less real.

You Might Also Like