Which Edition Should I Choose?
As an immensely popular book, The Count of Monte Cristo is readily available in a number of abridged and unabridged editions. It may be appealing to teach an abridged edition – after all, Dumas’ initial is well over 1,000 pages long!
However, appointing your students an abridged edition of this book is likely to backfire. Unlike other long books (War and Peace, Les Miserables), The Count of Monte Cristo is not understood for prolonged philosophical variations, which could be eliminated while leaving the plot mostly undamaged. Rather, Dumas is all story: busy action, shocking twists and turns, all developing to exceptionally pleasing climaxes. At 500-700 pages, abridged variations undoubtedly exclude essential events, function many plot holes, and eventually confuse and annoy readers.
We advise picking one of the three options listed below:.
- Oxford World Classics: Based upon the original 1846 English translation of the unique, which is most frequently utilized today. The translators took minor liberties with Dumas’ original, reflecting Victorian social mores. For example, some recommendations to a lesbian character were reduced. Nevertheless, this variation keeps Dumas’ style and voice.
- Penguin Classics: A more recent translation by Robin Buss. This variation refashions Dumas’ language for a contemporary audience. As such, it might be easier for today’s readers to follow, but loses some credibility. It likewise reinserts the omissions discovered in the 1846 edition.
- Everyman’s Library: This variation likewise takes a modern method. It is also slightly much shorter than the initial, having been a little cut (but not considerably abridged).
The thought questions in this lesson strategy offer material and concepts that trainees can use to write brief initial essays. For the sake of improving the power of expression, instructors need to motivate trainees to compose on subjects that have actually been gone over in class, this time in the more formal writing style anticipated in a literary essay. At the very same time, students should not be discouraged from picking their own subjects.
The questions attended to the final paper are most appropriate for trainee essays. Keep in mind that grading an essay needs to not depend upon an easy list of required content.