StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Naomi Klein's Don't Fence Us in - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The problem statement for this study is to summarize, analyze, and synthesize aspects of  Naomi Klein’s essay, “Don’t Fence Us In.” The researcher states that Klein’s essay is a one-sided attack against capitalism in general and as an ideology…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
Naomi Kleins Dont Fence Us in
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Naomi Klein's Don't Fence Us in"

Naomi Klein's "Don't Fence Us in" The issue of how capitalism erect barriers that keep out parts of society from enjoying their rights to exercise their freedom and to partake in their share of resources such as water, electricity and education has been tied to policies such as privatization. In recent times on a worldwide scale, capitalism has been evident in free trade, as carried out by the World Trade Organization (WTO) and in the phenomenon called globalization. We can understand this issue by summarizing, analyzing, and synthesizing aspects of Naomi Klein’s essay, “Don’t Fence Us In.

” Klein’s essay uses the metaphor of the fence to describe the barriers that come up every time capitalist policies are enforced. The fence here can be virtual as to stop or paralyze people from exercising their freedom The fence can real and visible, as when governments or powerful groups prop up security apparatuses to keep out workers or activists from getting too close in their protests against capitalism. She describes capitalism as the all-source or origin of state policies such as privatization, of World Bank missives to borrower-governments dictating fiscal or budgetary priorities, and to the recent phenomenon of globalization.

On the other hand, she also writes that capitalism is dismantling “necessary fences” such as the one protecting schools from being invaded by advertisements, an example of a public space being overtaken by the private sphere.Klein’s essay is a one-sided attack against capitalism in general and as an ideology. The purpose is to dominate and discredit capitalism for being the all-source of the negative manifestations of privatization, of the continuing debate on free trade and globalization and of even on the issue of what are behind genetically-modified food.

Her arguments are too all-embracing as they try to tackle several issues all at once, and point to one single cause, capitalism. The author certainly wins many points in bringing up ethical and emotional arguments against the enemy, capitalism. She does this by bringing up the casualties or victims of policies that can be tied to capitalism. However, the fact that capitalism as an economic system being espoused by governments or powerful groups does not mean that it is the only factor or cause of policies such as privatization or of the phenomenon called globalization.

She fails in being clear and logical to prop up her issues. There may be truth to the statement that capitalism leave out the less powerful and the poor from participating in a free market environment, but it is not valid to argue that it is the single cause for fencing out the less-powerful. In globalization, for example – there are so many factors that are at work, aside from capitalism as an ideology espoused by governments. The movement of labor and capital can be tied to many causes such as migration issues (people are fleeing because of political persecution and restrictive conditions or they may simply long for a “better life” in other countries, not just because there’s more money or opportunities outside their country).

There is in fact a raging debate in the so-called capitalist West of who will benefit in outsourcing work to low-cost countries. There are political forces at work, whether they be governments, politicians, businesses, citizens, etc. Here, the free-market is at work in its real meaning – but Klein failed to bring up this point. Capitalism indeed can erect “fences” and there are casualties. But in some of its manifestations such as globalization, it may yet bring many benefits as is already evident in less-developed countries getting work away from less-than efficient market in the so called capitalist West – a case of turning old-fashioned capitalism on its head,

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Naomi Klein's Don't Fence Us in Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1529858-rhetorical-analysis-on-naomi-kleins-dont-fence-us-in
(Naomi Klein's Don'T Fence Us in Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1529858-rhetorical-analysis-on-naomi-kleins-dont-fence-us-in.
“Naomi Klein's Don'T Fence Us in Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1529858-rhetorical-analysis-on-naomi-kleins-dont-fence-us-in.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Naomi Klein's Don't Fence Us in

Fence Discrimination Defense

This is also noted by Naomi Klein in her article Don' fence us in.... hellip; However human society has taken the idea of a fence to limits that cannot be condoned or tolerated.... It is the argument of this paper that these fences should not be allowed to exist, that we should not fence people in, whether the context is moral, social or cultural.... Christina Kochemidova , in her article The Culture of the fence: Artifacts and Meanings, brings up the various contexts a fence can be looked at....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Prejudice and discrimination

Globalization has become a byword in contemporary times and the term is used to describe the present connectivity of different cities of the world as a result of economic and financial activities.... The global village has shrunk as a result of developments in the field of communication and technology....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Experience Economy

Lets look how experience economy helps in the industrial growth.... International trade is a way to achieve a higher standard of living and improving the per capita income and GDP growth for all trading nations.... The post war (WWI and WWII) era has seen a rapid expansion of trade in the trading sections among all the trading nations....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Don't Ask, Don't Tell

These legal reasons have been recognized in other countries too and form the basis for many countries' rejection of similar don't ask, don't tell policies.... Since the don't ask, don't tell policy came into effect, thousands of soldiers have been forced to leave service....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Naomi Campbells Recent Testimony

In this paper " naomi Campbell's Recent Testimony" the author discusses the Special Court of Sierra Leone, the role it plays in the status quo of a war-torn country, whether it fulfills its objective of upholding justice and fairness and finally, the pressure put upon this special court of Sierra Leone....
14 Pages (3500 words) Case Study

How to Build a New World

On the perspective of Klein, she admits that people use this phenomenon-of creating new sets of economic How to Build a New World Identify naomi Kleins main idea Klein is concerned with what is the initiative, which peopleshould take to make the world a better place.... What is naomi Kleins tone?... naomi Klein and the anti-globalization movement....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Mecca Cola World Company

Pepsi has an edge in the sense that it has also been targeting people who currently don't have a cola preference or those who stick to other drinks like tea or even plain water.... The essay "Mecca Cola World Company" discusses the soft drink industry from the perspective of Muslim countries....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Naomi by Tanizaki

hellip; From this paper, it is clear that Tanizaki's naomi is a true depiction of the Modern Girl or Moga of that age.... Just like Tanizaki described naomi, Silverberg described Moga as extremely feminine.... Tanizaki's naomi and Silverberg's Moga pursue sexual freedom.... Your full February 16, naomi by Tanizaki Miriam Silverberg calls the Modern Girl of Japan in 1920s-30s as moga.... For Silverberg, Tanizaki's naomi is a true depiction of the Modern Girl or moga of that age....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us