StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analyzing Foreign Aid Failure - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Analyzing Foreign Aid Failure" discusses aid to poor nations that is indeed praiseworthy. However, given the different factors that we have elucidated, it will be a fruitless endeavor. There’s also the issue of foreign aid making the poor country dependent…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER99% of users find it useful
Analyzing Foreign Aid Failure
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analyzing Foreign Aid Failure"

Analyzing Foreign Aid Failure The word 'aid' is taken to mean helping someone. Place the word 'foreign' before it and you now have a term used to denote help coming from a nation directed to another nation in need. In spite of the billions of dollars that have been pledged and delivered for the past years, many of the receiving nations still remain poor while some have even become worse. Ideally, the desire to aid emanates from our moral values and humane aspirations that need to be fulfilled.

In some cases, however, foreign nations are designed to make another nation subservient - thus, the "we give you money, you give us business perks and alliance" principle. Many scholars have formulated views on why foreign aid is a venture doomed to fail. We examine the prospect using the competitive, individualistic, and competitive views. The competitive view states that nations use foreign aid as a means of gaining a political and economic advantage over other nations. What drives them is the desire to polarize power towards them.

We can find many examples of this in history. The Cold War saw the Soviet Union and the United States pouring out aid to countries that pledge allegiance to them. Cuba saw crude oil worth billions of dollars coming from the USSR with the agreement that they let the USSR build missile silos directed against major cities of the United States. The United States was also guilty of buying out allegiances such as pre-war Vietnam and the Philippines. Foreign aid fails to fulfill its function of helping others because allegiances imply certain trade-offs.

Trade liberalization, for example, opens up the poor country's market to the donor. What happens is that the local industry fails to grow because they can't compete with the highly mechanized firms of the donor. Donors would also require that the poor country direct the majority of its export destinations to them and prohibit them from doing any kind of business with the other 'competitors'. Yet, to protect their own industries, the donors would impose prohibitive tariffs on the products making it unsustainable for the poor country to export.

In some cases, foreign aid would come in the form of foreign debt. The Philippines, for example, received foreign debts from the United States. What happened was that after the Asian economic crisis and local political instability, the peso deteriorated against the dollar. Since the debt was to be repaid in dollars, it has tripled in value and is now eating up the majority of the country's national budget. Essentially, the receiving country is at the mercy of the donor. The individualistic view does not delve so much into competition and is more of an "as long as we are stable, we will help you" principle.

In other words, this view takes on the logic of "we will give you what we can spare". The problem with this is more of the continuity of aid delivery and may even be as serious as no delivery at all. Thus, we see road networks, dams, and health programs funded by foreign aid in an incomplete and deteriorating condition due to the failure of delivery. The optimistic view would be that of programs and infrastructures completed. However, these projects become so problematic that they become useless in the long run due below standard materials used in construction and inappropriate policies adopted in the program.

What causes them None other than the limitation in the budget from the aid. In the cooperative view, foreign aid comes from the genuine desire to help with no strings attached. This is particularly true in foreign aids directed to African nations where billions of dollars have been pouring in. Yet, even with the best of efforts, African nations are still grappling with poverty, illiteracy, and famine. Africa has failed to improve even with the volume of aid. The problem, using the cooperative view, is that for foreign aid to even enter, donors must make concessions such as giving rations to armed militants so they will allow food bought with the aid to even come in.

Mismanagement also comes to the scene as local officials become enamored with corruption due to the sudden influx of affluence. There's also the issue of foreign aid making the poor country dependent instead of making them able to sustain themselves in the long run. Giving out aid to poor nations is indeed praiseworthy. However, given the different factors that we have elucidated, it will be a fruitless endeavors.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“International Politics Explain why foreign aid does not work as Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1513150-international-politics-explain-why-foreign-aid-does-not-work-as-intended-in-competitive-individualistic-cooperative-views
(International Politics Explain Why Foreign Aid Does Not Work As Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1513150-international-politics-explain-why-foreign-aid-does-not-work-as-intended-in-competitive-individualistic-cooperative-views.
“International Politics Explain Why Foreign Aid Does Not Work As Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1513150-international-politics-explain-why-foreign-aid-does-not-work-as-intended-in-competitive-individualistic-cooperative-views.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analyzing Foreign Aid Failure

The impact on China foreign exchange reserve if china aids European union debt crisis

Therefore China is planning to give aid to European Union so that the economic condition in European region becomes more stabilised.... European countries are in need of aid and investment and it has been predicted that some of the countries like Greece and others might not be able to pay off their loan and therefore these countries will default.... hina is planning to give aid to European countries and China is looking this aid as an investment to keep its economic growth....
35 Pages (8750 words) Dissertation

Creative Accounting

The globalisation regime has brought about many changes to the corporate landscape.... Intense amount of competition amongst the rival brands and companies is one such change which has benefitted the consumers in general.... .... ... ... The manipulations have taken place in different forms.... While analysing the creative accounting in the context of Greek, Baralexis (2004) found out that the manipulation of accounting has been well documented in accounting literatures and there are examples of manipulation in account books dating back to 1920s....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Shifting Power to Make a Difference

Perhaps driven by the desire to help the less opportune or gain new markets and alliances or to correct past mistakes especially the acts committed during the colonial era where impoverished countries of today where divested of their resources, nations and organizations are extending their hand in the form of financial aid. ... he problems that faces the institutions that handle international aid - whether they may be on the supply side or intermediaries- is how to best utilize the fund such that the intended improvements for the beneficiary are achieved....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Government Failure in Iceland

Doing so means to look at the nature of government failure within the Icelandic government and to understand how the entire political system directly or indirectly allows for leeway which often leads to lack of accountability.... This may also play a key role in reestablishing the trust between Iceland and foreign governments....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

External Environment Analysis of Ice-Fili - Russian-Based Ice Cream Company

From the case analysis, it is evident that the transformation of the Russian closed economy to an open economy greatly assisted foreign firms to enter the country and this situation raised potential challenges to the market leadership of Ice-Fili.... The company gave primary focus to product quality and therefore it continued to use natural ingredients while foreign manufacturers widely used chemical preservatives to increase the durability of their ice cream products....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

How dialysis treatment for kidney failure relies on an understanding of the principles of diffusion

The dialysis procedure removes solutes and toxins from the blood.... This procedure depends on the passive movement of water and solutes across a semi-permeable membrane.... ... ... ... Naturally, the kidney organ is a dialyzing organ.... When blood passes through the kidney, essential compounds are separated from harmful compounds....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Is Bill Gates Correct in the View that Foreign Aid Truly Matters

The paper "Is Bill Gates Correct in the View that foreign aid Truly Matters?... underlines that with the evident progress that aid has contributed to, it would be justifiable to call for the developed economies to raise the fraction that they contribute to foreign aid.... Bill Gates has researched the issue of foreign aid being issued to developing countries and is against the myth that foreign aid does not work to improve the livelihood of the citizens in the countries that receive it....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Foreign Direct Investment

As the report, foreign Direct Investment, declares FDI promotes the competition in the domestic input market.... In addition, the risk of political instability threatens to destabilize the operations of foreign investments.... This essay presents FDI which involves the ownership of entities abroad for production, research and development, access of raw materials and other resources....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us