StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Issues of Employment Law - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper "The Issues of Employment Law" presents four cases introducing people who have some problems connected with labor law. For example, Susan who is being criticized by the center manager publicly who finally demotes her to Assistant head of the department, without decreasing her salary…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
The Issues of Employment Law
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Issues of Employment Law"

Case 2 Six months back Susan had entered into a contract for employment with Leisurama Co. Ltd. as Head of its Marketing Department. In the last four months, she is being consistently criticised by the centre manager publicly who finally demotes her to Assistant head of the department, without decreasing her salary. As a result, Susan resigns with immediate effect. The CEO of the company, Michael is therefore advised on the legal stance of Susan vis-à-vis the company, in case of any legal dispute. In case of any legal dispute with the said employee, the company has weak legal standing so far as the legalities are concerned. The voluntary resignation of Susan may have grave repercussions for the company as the said employee has several valid reasons to file claim in employment tribunal under more than one clause. Since the company has written agreement with the employee for not necessarily following the company’s grievance procedures, she can directly make her appeal to the employment tribunal. Susan, the said employee is a bonafide employee, employed under the contract of employment as head of the marketing department. She had resigned from her post when she was demoted to the post of assistant head of the marketing department. She was left with no option but to resign under the circumstances. She has legal right to claim her resignation under the following clauses of ‘constructive dismissal’ under ERA 1996 s.95(1)(c) that say an employee who resigns "in circumstances such that he is entitled to terminate [his contract] without notice by reason of the employers conduct" (internet). Another useful summary of the position was provided by the EAT in a 2003 case in which the judge said that "In relation to constructive dismissal, in broad terms, there have to be four elements. There has to be a breach of contract by the employer which can be either an actual breach or an anticipatory breach, and the breach must be sufficiently important to justify the employee resigning; or it can be one of the last of a series of incidents which justifies leaving. The two other conditions normally are that the employee must leave in response to the breach and not for some other unconnected reason, and, finally, the employee must not take too long about it" (France v Westminster City Council, EAT on 9th May 2003) (breach of contract, internet). Susan was not given any prior notice and her demotion to the post of assistant head of marketing clearly violated her terms and conditions of her contract of employment thus compounding her claim of constructive dismissal with breach of contract that specifically states that one cannot be change the terms of the contract that includes the designation, without giving appropriate notice and reasons to the employee. The employer must ensure that the employee is given a chance to defend herself or himself. No such notice was given to the employee in this case and neither was she given any chance to defend herself. Arden v Bradley (1994) IRLR 490 clearly collaborates with Susan’s case that they must not attempt unilaterally to reduce an employees status or pay (Arden, internet). Susan has a strong case of ‘bullying or breach of confidence’ because from the time, new manager Pauline took over (four months back), Pauline has been consistently criticizing Susan publicly and in front of her juniors which may have resulted in her loss of self confidence, respect and leading to stress. In Morrow v Safeway Stores plc [2002] IRLR 9, the Employment Tribunal said it thought that the public criticism by the store manager was a breach of the implied term of trust and confidence. Susan though, strongly qualifying under the clause but cannot claim compensation because of her short period of employment which is just 6 months. Then again, if Susan decides to claim financial compensation against the psychological and stress related ailments after her resignation, her claims can be dismissed as per the judgment in the case of Johnson Unisys Ltd. where the lordships held that employee could not use breach of implied terms of trust and confidence to claim damages for psychological injury if the damage arose because of the manner of dismissal (injury, internet). It therefore, can be said that Susan has strong case under ‘constructive dismissal’ and stands to gain substantial financial remuneration as compensation Case 3 Kate has been in employment with the company as Office manager in Barchester for the last five and a half years. Kate is given a written notice for dismissal under the reason of redundancy. But at the same time, she’s offered a post of Senior Administrator, at the company’s headquarter based in London with the same pay scale and a relocation package. She rejects the offer citing children’s welfare as her main reason for refusal. Michael is duly advised and given legal status regarding the dismissal of Kate under redundancy and her financial entitlements as per statutory redundancy payments. Michael must be made aware of the clauses of redundancy under which the employees can be made redundant or dismissed. The main reasons being; new technology or a new system has made your job unnecessary, the job you were hired for no longer exists, the need to cut costs means staff numbers must be reduced or the business is closing down or moving (Redundancy, internet). None of the above reasons hold good for the company as it looks to be in sound financial state and is neither planning to introduce any new technology. There has also been no plan to dismiss more employees as cost cutting measures. The Redundancy clause therefore, cannot be applied for a Kate and the reasons cited by the administration clearly violate redundancy clause. Secondly, since the dismissal of Kate under redundancy clause is null and void, it can be legally construed as unfair dismissal with the malafide intention of upsetting Kate and against which she has genuine case for filing a claim in employment tribunal. She qualifies for this claim as she has been in service for more than five years. Thirdly, the alternative job offer to Kate based in London must have her consent and approval as she is a single parent with two teenaged children. She is perfectly entitled to refuse the said offer under family commitment as the children are well adjusted in their school and children’s grandparents not only provide moral and emotional support but the children are close to them and spend a lot of time with them. They feel secure with them while their mother is out working. Kate is therefore entitled to compensation. In the case that she wins her claim, the tribunal can order the employer to pay compensation, which is unlimited for discrimination or dismissal on health and safety grounds. For unfair dismissal claims the award is made up of: the basic award (calculated based on your on age and length of service), and a compensatory award, which has a maximum limit of £58,400. For wrongful dismissal or other breaches of contract, up to £25,000 can be awarded. Compensation is intended to replace lost earnings - theres no payment for hurt feelings (apart from in discrimination cases). You have to try to reduce your loss (for example, by getting another job or claiming benefit). The tribunal can order your employer to give you your job back if you win a dismissal case, if you want it. (wrongful dismissal, internet). Case 4 Janet is physiotherapist at the leisure centre and wants to move over to a half time contract and her request for the same is refused by the centre manager Pauline on the ground that her it is not appropriate for professional staff to work part time and the customers may get upset if they are not able to consult same professional, when required. Janet writes to Michael asking for a formal grievance hearing under company’s grievance procedures, stating that she is a victim of sex discrimination and will have to resign and bring tribunal claim if she is not allowed to opt for half time employment. Michael has been given the following advice regarding the legal status of Janet and whether her request for flexible timing has substantial support for him to accede to her demand. As per the legal clause for an employee to request for flexible work arrangement, the employee must qualify under the following conditions; - The employee must have worked for 26 weeks - are responsible for a child as a parent/guardiand/ special guardian/ foster parent/ private foster carer or as a holder of a residence order - are the spouse, partner or civil partner of one of these - are applying to care for a child - or are a carer who cares or expects to be caring, for a spuse, a partner, a civil partner, a relative or who lives at the same address as the person being cared for. So far as Janet is concerned, none of the above reasons apply to her to apply for the changeover to the part time work arrangement. Another very pertinent point is that her professional services are required by the company for its customers and therefore refusal to her request is not only correct legally but ethically also because Janet works in a services based industry which is dependent on client satisfaction. - Janet had been employed as a full time physiotherapist and there has been no medical or family compulsion on the part of Janet to opt for part time. Another reason that Michael has strong legal position is that Janet has threatened to use the clause of being a victim of sex discrimination if her demand for part time work is not accepted and she would then be claiming the same from the tribunal. If she takes her case to the tribunal as threatened, the company is inclined to win the case as her claim or threat of sex discrimination is not only a blatant lie but her claim is libellous and may prove counter productive for her in any legal dispute with the company. It therefore can be stated that in case of her resignation without any notice as per the term and conditions of her employment contract, she is liable to forfeit any claim whatsoever. It can therefore be stated that in case of any legal dispute, Janet would not only lose her present job but her professional integrity and credibility. The company stands on strong legal position. Reference Law of Constructive dismissal. Available from: [Accessed 10 January, 2008]. Breach of contract. Available from: [Accessed 10 January, 2008]. Arden v Bradley. Available from: < http://employment-law-expert.co.uk/ucd2.htm> [Accessed 10 January, 2008]. Psychological injury. Available from: < http://www.webnotes.co.uk/articles/Compensation.pdf> [Accessed 10 January, 2008]. Redundancy. Available from: [Accessed 10 January, 2008]. Wrongful Dismissal. Available from: [Accessed 10 January, 2008]. Flexible Work Arrangement. Available from: [Accessed 10 January, 2008]. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Issues of Employment Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1816 words - 1, n.d.)
The Issues of Employment Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1816 words - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1711250-employment-law
(The Issues of Employment Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1816 Words - 1)
The Issues of Employment Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1816 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/law/1711250-employment-law.
“The Issues of Employment Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1816 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1711250-employment-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Issues of Employment Law

Negotiation between Law Firms for Solving the Issues on Determining the Employment of the Employee

t is critical to understand that You Can have actually made an offer of employment to Mary which was duly accepted against the consideration of wages.... This essay " Negotiation between Law Firms for Solving the issues on Determining the Employment of the Employee" discusses cases presented differently but connecting legal issues to be dealt with therefore I focused on identifying the resources.... nbsp; According to the English Contract law, a contract is formed when there is an offer, acceptance, and consideration therefore a valid contract has to contain these elements to be enforceable at law....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Termination of Employment

Name Date Professor April 19, 2013 employment law Case Study 1 Employers are by law allowed to terminate any form of employment by giving appropriate notice period of the intention to terminate the employment relationship between the employer and the employee.... hellip; The termination of employment may be due to a ‘Just Cause', which is committed before the time the employee is dismissed.... “Just Cause” action provides that an employee is liable for punishment for performing the duties or tasks contrary to either the express or implied instructions or terms of employment....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Employment Law - ABC Manufacturing Company

employment law employment law seeks to act as a guideline for sound practices by employers and employees in the work environment to safeguard them from exploitation and unethical practices.... … Name: Instructor: Course: Date: employment law employment law seeks to act as a guideline for sound practices by employers and employees in the work environment to safeguard them from exploitation and unethical practices.... These challenges can be addressed using the guidelines set out by the employment law....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

To be emloyed on wages

To Be Employed On Wages Name: Institution: To Be Employed On Wages Introduction There is no actual answer to the question as to which form of employment between wage and self is better.... To Be Employed On Wages To Be Employed On Wages Introduction There is no actual answer to the question as to which form of employment between wage and self is better.... Therefore, with this in mind, it is vital to look at the pros and cons of each type of employment in order to see why this paper supports wage employment....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Relationship of the Employer and Employee

In… Thus, the employer may exercise its prerogative to terminate the employee through the processes as enunciated in the ACAS (Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration If the employee finds the termination unlawful then redress may be undertaken before the employment tribunal.... Dismissal is deemed just when anchored on the employee's misconduct, inability to discharge the duties due to lack of qualifications, the position is redundant, continued employment is prohibited by statutory duty and other analogous reasons....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Social Issue

Unemployment is a situation that occurs when the number of qualified persons seeking employment opportunities supersedes the amount of the existing job opportunities hence leading to a situation of higher number of jobless person in a specific region (topics.... In many cases, social issues may also be referred as social problems; they affect various facets of the society regardless of the size as well as the composition.... This occurs due… o the fact members of the society living close to one another experience conflict from time to time due to the different types of relationships that exists: Social issues are societal facets that cannot be avoided; in some cases, even persons living in the same house may There are various types of social issues that affect the current generation, they include; religious affiliations, sexual orientations, unemployment, racism, domestic violence as well as pollution....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Employment Law Case Analysis

The health benefits employment law al Affiliation) Summary of Issues Tomas worked for a total of 200 hours of overtime.... This should be effective within seven days of employment termination.... Tomas termination of employment was inappropriate, as his employment with Crown Company lasted for more than three months.... This is because in case of employment termination the pay in lieu of notice is effective within seven days after the termination date....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Evaluation of The Poverty Issue in US Economy

Therefore, the essay addresses such related topics as immigration, employment, education, and production.... The current essay would shed light on the causes and measures that can be taken in order to reduce the spread of poverty across the United States.... hellip; Many people who have existed on this planet have been frantically poor....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us