StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Union versus non-union - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The issue under consideration is pivotal in the free market economies as they are capital driven and have to hire skilled personnel to accomplish varied tasks in the procurement, production, marketing and distribution of goods and services…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Union versus non-union
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Union versus non-union"

Union versus Non-Union of the of the Concerned January 7, Union versus Non-Union The issue under consideration is pivotal in the free market economies as they are capital driven and have to hire skilled personnel to accomplish varied tasks in the procurement, production, marketing and distribution of goods and services. There is no denying the fact that the capitalist classes enjoy leverage over other aspects of production like labor owing to their financial wherewithal and acumen. On the contrary, in the case of skilled personnel, of all the possible leverages available to them, their collective bargaining power is the most important factor that can help them match the pecuniary power and authority of their employers.

As each person is endowed with a different and unique emotional mind set, skill proficiency, aspirations and job expectations, conflict is the natural outcome of free market operations. In a conflict scenario, solidarity with peers could serve as an accessible empowering factor, while negotiating with one’s resourceful employers. The objective of this paper is to identify and analyze the salient advantages and disadvantages of unions with an analytical approach, to enable the interested stakeholders decide as to their validity or futility.

It would be prudent to begin with picking up the possible advantages of joining unions. Mulvey and Neo (1999), on the basis of a prolonged study, found that there existed a wage difference of 10 to 15 percent between the union affiliated and non-union workers. A possible conclusion is that perhaps the non-union workers find it difficult to exercise a profitable bargaining ability with their employers. This premise is rationally understandable. It should be easier to approach an employer regarding a grievance in a collective manner.

A collective approach towards conflict resolution does not put a single worker on the line. This also to some extent makes an employer more flexible and willing towards conflict resolution, as the outcome of failing to assuage a collective workforce is bound to be more debilitating than failing to fairly treat a single worker. The hypothesis put forward by Mulvey and Neo (1999) could logically be extrapolated to other aspects of work environment like work conditions, daily breaks, safety issues, health benefits, retirement benefits and the like, for as per the scientific study of Mulvey and Neo, if a non-union worker is more prone to face wage inequalities, one is certainly more vulnerable to inequalities in other aspects of one’s job.

Realistically speaking, besides giving a sense of belonging and redemption from victimization, unions could and often do make it affordable for an individual worker or a group to resort to other modes of conflict resolution like the courts of law. It is understandable that a single worker or a small group may not have the financial wherewithal to bear the costs associated with legal procedures; a union can garner massive funds by imposing a nominal membership fee on its adherents, in direct proportion to their wages.

The funds so accumulated could be used by a union to succor its members in their hour of distress. Hence, unions do offer multiple benefits to any interested applicant, that are leverage before employers, safety from possible persecution, a sense of belonging and camaraderie, access to the statutory rights and financial, moral and legal support during difficult times. It is a known fact and almost all workers who are union members know that trade unions charge a fee for extending membership. So, union membership comes with a price.

It may be nominal, still it is there. However, this sacrifice to a great extent may not seem much to some, considering the benefits offered by unions. According to the research of Addison, Heywood and Wei (2003), the one prominent problem with unions is that they instill a kind of herd mentality in their members. What is a crisis for one may seem ignorable to other. There exists a valid and recognizable probability that all the workers may not agree with a decision taken by a union at some time or other.

Yet, union membership makes it obligatory for a worker to support the decisions and activism resorted to by a union. Unions do profess to support democratic values. Yet, considering the human nature and practical experience, there does exists a possibility to earn the ire of some if not all union members and leaders, if one tows a line contrary to the union stand. Not to mention the possibility of being isolated and ignored during a professional crisis of one’s own. Conclusively, very few will dare to do so.

One wonders, how many enterprises may have collapsed, irrespective of the disagreement of a majority of their workers with a more aggressive union leadership. According to Bernhardt, McGrath and Defilippis (2008), there is no dearth of instances when the potential employers desist from hiring workers who are union members or even sympathizers. Their logic is readily understandable. For an employer, it is easier to deal with and bargain with a single worker then negotiating with one’s collective workforce, especially more so, when the job of that worker is dependent on the goodwill of that employer.

So, in a way, union membership may cut on the chances of employability of a worker. A non-union worker is always free to work for any employer, irrespective of what the union thinks. The same study by Bernhardt, McGrath and Defilippis (2008) states that not all the union members tend to be politically active or informed at any time. In such a scenario, there exists a valid possibility that a union leadership may be hijacked by vested interests who may adhere to their own personal agenda or connive with the owners to dupe workers.

The intent of this paper by its very nature is analytical and not conclusive. Ultimately it depends on a workers choice as to join a union or not. Unions do promise a collective bargaining power and support during a crisis. Yet, they also sometimes limit the chances of getting employed and the freedom to act as per one’s conscience. References Addison, John. T, Heywood, John. S & Wei, Xiangdong. (2003). New Evidence of Unions and Plant Closings: Britain in the 1990s. Southern Economic Journal, 69(4), 822-827.

Bernhardt, Annette, McGrath, Siobhan & Defilippis, James. (2008). The State of Workers Protections in the United States: Unregulated Work in New York City. International Labor Review, 147(2/3), 135-144. Mulvey, C & Neo, L.M. (1999). Union Wage Effects and the Extent of Organization. Australian Journal of Labor Economics, 3, 65-92.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Union versus non-union Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1405013-union-versus-non-union
(Union Versus Non-Union Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/history/1405013-union-versus-non-union.
“Union Versus Non-Union Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1405013-union-versus-non-union.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Union versus non-union

Determinants of Belonging to a Union

The rationale of this paper is to investigate the factors that determine the entry into a union.... hellip; The general assumption is that the older and married populace will increase the probability of being in a union.... Determinants of Belonging to a union This study establishes that an average person who never attended college and lives outside the South and the Central City earns an average hourly rate of $7.... This study intends to test all these assumptions and examine a model of the determinant factors of belonging to a union....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Importance of Trade Creation Versus Trade Diversion

The Benefits and Costs of Increased Trade Integration Between Countries Depends on the Relative Importance of Trade Creation versus Trade Diversion, Plus The Dynamic Gains From Integration Name Institution Recent years has seen economies of various countries in the world grow by greater margins.... However, it is not clear whether the benefits and costs of increased trade integration between these countries depends on the relative importance of trade creation versus trade diversion, plus the dynamic gains from integration....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Aviation Unions And The Aviation Industry

Flying for pleasure and adventure began with some European inventors experimented with hot air balloons and gliders.... However the first powered flight took place on December 17, 1903, when Orville Wright and his brother Wilbur Wright made their historic flights at Kitty Hawk, North Carolina. … On January 1, 1914, a group of Florida businessmen launched the first scheduled air service using a powered airplane....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Long Term Effects of Being a Non-Union Actor

In 1995-1996, there were a series of articles that dealt with the issue of Union versus non-union pay rates for extras.... This research is being carried out to show that non-union actors suffer from low self-esteem after working as an extra for a long period due to the significantly lower pay rate they receive as opposed to union actors who work as extras.... hellip; The study leads to the conclusion that not only do non-union actors receive less pay, they receive poorer quality amenities than their union counterparts, non-union actors have a challenging time in gaining admission to the union due to stringent rules and expensive initiation fees which all combine to create an atmosphere of intense anxiety....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Biological Versus Non Biological Parents

While the difficulty is actually asking about which mom or dad contributes to a biological connection with the child, answering that they both are true mom and dad concentrates on the question at a much deeper stage.... This reaction points out two significant facts.... hellip; First, that the two contribute to equal parenting responsibilities, and second, that the biological association has negligible importance in defining the relations. These realities turn into even more vital if a couple ends their link to each other....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

HR Strategy Responding to a Union Organizing Drive

The company, on the other hand, needs to be aware of all the rules of NLRA and also the fact that if the elections took place and the union was not voted then there would be an appeal.... In case the union is at fault, an election may be held by an understanding between the head honcho and the singular or work association guaranteeing to speak to the representatives....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Psychological Problems of People at Work Who Are Not in Trade Unions

The paper "Psychological Problems of People at Work Who Are Not in Trade Unions" shows that non-union actors suffer from low self-esteem after working as an extra for a long period due to the significantly lower pay rate they receive as opposed to union actors who work as extras.... non-union extras should be paid for the work they perform as handsomely as union workers.... Challenges in Obtaining Union MembershipIn the previous section, it was discussed that pay levels were not equivalent for union and non-union extras....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Decline of Unions in America

The parties that stand against each other is the management versus the union.... Hirsch at Georgia State University suggested in an analysis that the number of government employees in Wisconsin belonged to a union dropped by 48,000 last year to 139,000 from 187,000 (Greenhouse, 2013).... As soon as the Republican-led legislature weakened the union's bargaining rights workers started to quit their memberships.... It has been observed from the history of union activities that organized labor normally supports candidates from the Democratic Party....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us