StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Robinson vs. Jacksonville Shipyards - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “The Robinson vs. Jacksonville Shipyards’ the author discusses the case, which dealt with the claim of a woman by the name of Lois Robinson and other female employees who stated male employees were creating a hostile work environment…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
The Robinson vs. Jacksonville Shipyards
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Robinson vs. Jacksonville Shipyards"

Download file to see previous pages

The court did, in fact, find in favor of the female employees and also found that the elimination of sexual discrimination was more important than preserving the free speech rights of those inflicting pain and discomfort through their words and actions. Yet, there have been cases in which other courts have found that telling sexual jokes or displaying sexual images is not a form of sexual harassment. That brings about the questions of whether or not the treatment of Lois Robinson and the other women of Jacksonville Shipyards should really be considered a form of sex discrimination.

It also makes one wonder that if the managers of Jacksonville Shipyards acknowledged the treatment as morally wrong, would they agree or disagree that the male employees did anything illegal In Robinson vs. Jacksonville Shipyards, the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida found in favor of the women who made claims that the male workers of Jacksonville Shipyards engaged in sexually offensive acts. These acts included sexually degrading comments being made as well as sexually explicit images of women hanging in obvious places around the workplace (Manske, 2003).

Now one must take into consideration that Lois Robinson was not pressured for sexual favors, was not denied any advancement or a wage increase because of the treatment she was receiving, and she did not suffer a mental breakdown due to the treatment. What it comes down to is that she was offended.Sexual Harassment is defined by the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) as unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors verbally or physically. The definition further states that if submission, or lack thereof, has an impact on one's employment status or, if such conduct interferes with the work of the individual being affected, creating an intimidating, hostile or offensive work environment, that such actions are considered sexual harassment.

As for sexual discrimination, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 states that employment discrimination is prohibited based on race, color, sex, age or national origin. These prohibitions are also included in sexual harassment (Unknown, 1998).It is fair to state that Lois Robinson and the women of Jacksonville Shipyards experienced some form of both sexual harassment and sexual discrimination. When one looks at both Title VII and the laws set forth by the EEOC, Lois Robinson experienced discrimination based on her sex and experienced acts that created an intimidating, hostile and offensive work environment.

It is clear to see that the case falls into both categories, yet the harassment she received did not cover all the qualifying offenses. That is because only one of the offenses within these laws needs to be committed to qualifying as sexual harassment or sexual discrimination (Heathfield, n.d.).Legalities of their actions If Jackson shipyards were to admit that what their male employees did was morally wrong, but denied that their employees did anything illegal, would they be justified in this logic The truth is that they would not be justified?

Under federal, state, and some city laws, sexual harassment and/or discrimination in the workplace are illegal acts. 

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Robinson vs. Jacksonville Shipyards Case Study, n.d.)
The Robinson vs. Jacksonville Shipyards Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1523358-bus-ethicsjacksonville-shipyards-case
(The Robinson Vs. Jacksonville Shipyards Case Study)
The Robinson Vs. Jacksonville Shipyards Case Study. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1523358-bus-ethicsjacksonville-shipyards-case.
“The Robinson Vs. Jacksonville Shipyards Case Study”. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1523358-bus-ethicsjacksonville-shipyards-case.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Robinson vs. Jacksonville Shipyards

Workplace Ethical Dilemma: Pornography in the workplace

This form of sexual harassment had been the subject of the Robinson versus jacksonville shipyards case as well (Schultz).... A close friend of mine from Connecticut was in ninth grade when her teacher began calling her up on the phone to ask how she felt in his classroom, having obtained her phone number easily from the students' telephone book annually issued by her high school....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Henry Peach Robinson

One of the most prominent influences in the history of photography has been Henry Peach robinson (1830-1901), the English photographer and theoretician whose photographic tools, styles, and contributions turned out to be the corner stone of modern photography.... The best-known nineteenth-century popularizer of fine-art principles among photographers was Henry Peach robinson, an English commercial photographer who published a series of popular studio manuals introducing design concepts such as balance (of lines and mass), composition (of figures and lines), and chiaroscuro to both American and European photographers....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Operation Management of Viktor Lenac Shipyard

This small town boasts of two shipyards and one of them is the famous Viktor Lenac Shipyard (formerly known as Lazarus).... Because of political turbulence during the next ten years, foreign buyers hesitated to give business to Croatian shipyards.... During the Yugoslavian days, all shipyards were owned by the government but Croatia decided to opt for the open market economy and privatized the shipyards....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Jacksonville Shipyards

It may not be offensive jacksonville shipyards jacksonville shipyards Although the behavior of Robinson's male coworkers is morally objectionable, should management attempt to prevent it?... uppose the managers of jacksonville shipyards admit that her treatment was morally wrong but deny that they or her male coworkers did anything illegal.... Yes, management should attempt to prevent the morally objectionable actions of the male co-workers of robinson because it is a form of sexual harassment....
1 Pages (250 words) Research Paper

Marine Ship Yard

hellip; While in 2009 the portfolio of new orders of European shipyards was at 4 percent lower than in 2008.... With this drop down, the shipbuilding industry belongs to the It has negative impacts on many shipbuilding companies and counties around the world due to the biggest overcapacity of shipyards such as the far greater supply of fleet that it requires by the market (Mickeviciene).... In terms its benefits and financial impact, the recommendation will hit hard the shipyards....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

The Impact That Different Types of Leadership Have on Academic and Non-academic Outcomes

The second limitation is that the study did not conduct the leadership impact on both the academic and non-academic outcomes due to the limited number of studies that were available to make it practical (robinson 2008, 58).... Sets of leadership practices used in the second analyses includes goals and expectations establishment, resourcing, evaluating the curriculum and teaching process, coordinating and planning, promoting teacher's participation in the learning process and ensuring a supportive… The article has limitation i....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Water Supply Jacksonville Florida

The water supply of jacksonville Florida comes from the Floridian aquifer.... There are 115 Floridian wells that their water is pumped to a reservoir (jacksonville Electric Authority, 2014).... Water Supply jacksonville Florida Water Supply jacksonville Florida I live in jacksonville Florida.... The water supply of jacksonville Florida comes from the Floridian aquifer.... There are 115 Floridian wells that their water is pumped to a reservoir (jacksonville Electric Authority, 2014)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Injuries in Turkish Shipyards and on Turkish Vessels More Than the European Countries and The Solutions to Help

This assignment describes injuries in Turkish shipyards and on Turkish vessels and the solutions to help.... This paper outlines the importance of Maritime Business: the safety of shipyards and vessels.... It analyses different factors of accidents and ways of solution for Turkish shipyards.... An interesting comparison is made between the Turkish level of the mishap on shipyards and that of other European countries.... How often does an injury happen on other European vessels and shipyards?...
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us