StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Piece of Wax by Descartes - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "A Piece of Wax by Descartes" will explain judgment and imagination which are two faculties Descartes focuses on during his second meditation. How the mind observes things, why doubt is created, how perception and relativity changes with time, what expression looks like, how the mind, body and soul function as a unit…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
A Piece of Wax by Descartes
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Piece of Wax by Descartes"

?A Piece of Wax I. Introduction What a person perceives is mainly due to their knowledge of their surroundings which can be either known or unknown. Without the understanding of the human mind, it is hard to know the body. Descartes, during his meditation on a piece of wax said “it is now manifest to me that bodies themselves are not properly perceived by the senses nor by the faculty of imagination, but by the intellect alone.” The bulk of the essay will explain judgment and imagination which are two faculties Descartes focuses on during his second meditation. How the mind observes things, why doubt is created, how perception and relativity changes with time, what expression looks like, how the mind, body and soul function as a unit, and how a limited perception affect cognition can be explained by Descartes through is argument of judgment and imagination. There are many principles which create certain thought which will lead us to conclude something that is usually consistent and powerful. We guide our lives by these thoughts and ideas. And much of this comes about because of our faculties, which allows us to sense things in different magnitudes. Our five senses can lead us to believe in things that may fail us. During Descartes’ second meditation, he decides that everything he sees is not really there. What our eyes perceive may be a result of what the world has labeled to be real. But what our minds observe, gives us greater insight into the world around us. II. Our Mind’s Observations The observation of the world around Descartes has caused him to take a step back and view his life in a different manner. He creates doubt within his own mind because without doubt, he holds that one is naive in their thinking. Doubt allows for reflection and with reflection comes the knowledge of what needs to improve and how one may go about with the improvement. Without doubt, life in itself is blissful. The doubt that Descartes experiences is so powerful that he feels he can’t just forget what he is thinking. He has to act upon this new found doubt and get to the root of the problem. III. Doubt and Certainty For Descartes, the root of the problem is not doubt. Part of Descartes meditation lends closer towards finding out what is being doubted and he states that he will not rest until his longing to find what is certain is satisfied. He is so adamant to find a solution that he is willing to compromise. That compromise is him relinquishing all rights to finding what is certain and being ok with the fact that nothing may be certain in the end. Certainty is not guaranteed. In much of Descartes writings he makes arguments that cause one to think about their existence, the purpose of their existence and the end result. Observing a piece of wax lends towards his argument on the fact that the mind is more certainly known than the body due to perception. He says that all knowledge of external objects, including his body, could be false as a result of a demon. However, the idea that his mind exists cannot be a deception because his nature is not just made up of the body but also of a thinking thing. He says that even the corporal objects such as his own body is known more distinctly through the mind due to how the mind perceives what is in front of it. IV. Perception’s Relativity Perception is key to knowledge. Such is the idea of wax that Descartes was vehemently focusing on during his second meditation. As the wax melts, he believes that our minds begin to perceive its matter differently. Our mind realizes that the purpose of the wax has changed and can no longer be used in the way that the world has previously dictated. The properties create a new and yet meaningful definition that only our intellect can comprehend. Though the property of the wax may have changed, it now lends to a new purpose but keeps the same name. Our minds know and understand that regardless of the property the wax may be in during a particular state, it still is and will always be a piece of wax. Descartes claims that we know this through our faculty of judgment and not through our sense or our imagination. V. Faculty of Judgment and Imagination Imagination is extremely complex and Descartes believes that if Archemides could request something firm and absolute, then he too can have high expectations for finding the answer to his arguments. He therefore will not stop until he gets his answer regardless of what theory is proved in the end. (MII,P1) Maybe a higher power can give him answers to his questions. Calling on a higher power seems to be one of Descartes’ ways of confirming his beliefs and also doubts. He asks if there is not a God who orchestrates his mind to think the way it does. (MII,P2) Yet though those thoughts arise, he believes that it could just be he who is capable of thinking so intricately. Even those ponderings leads to less convoluted ideas of who he is and how his mind allows him to know his true identity. Though he attempts to discover his true identity, he also denies his very existence. (MII,P3) He believes he exists because he is constantly being persuaded that he does and this in itself is a form of deception. His own mind causes him to deceive his very essence, but he chooses not to allow that deception to keep him from believing that he truly exists. It is an act of will power and of desire that he will come to terms with the fact that he exists. He holds that he will be conscious that he exists. This means, he will know in his mind that he exists and not worry about having his existence depend on his physical being. It is not his physical being that dictates his status of existence. His existence is only true because he confirms he does exist via expression. VI. Expression Its not enough knowing that you exist but there is something more that is important to all humans. Descartes wants to know what he is. For him, existing is one thing, but knowing the matter of his existence is another. Once the matter of existence is known, life takes on new meaning. Cognition is the knowledge that he holds to be most evident. Without the mind space, the body is nothing. After all, it is the mind that dictates the actions of the body. The body can be a tricky tool. In retrospect, Descartes begins to search his past to help him understand his present. He says “what then did I think I was?” (MII,P5). He goes on to say that maybe he was an animal. His idea of an animal can be quite expansive so instead of delving into the details of what an animal consists of, he decides that he is human, and has all of the faculties of being a human. What he wonders about is his soul and how his soul could seem like something blowing in the wind, not being really part of the body but something that is also perceived. VII. Mind, Body and Soul He continues by experimenting with the soul. Maybe he is a soul and not a body at all. Maybe his mind is his soul, and therefore, detached from the body. The soul carries with it several attributes and the first attribute is the power of nutrition and walking. Without a body walking nor receiving nutrition is possible. Perception is an attribute but perception requires a body. He states that thinking is another attribute which belongs to the soul. If he thinks long enough, this is the length of his existence. “Mensive animus” is a thinking thing, which is a mind. Is he just a mind? He could be however, just something or someone who perceives or sentire. Sentire is nothing less than thinking. Perception and thought can be tied into one idea which creates an important faculty of the soul. Descartes reasons that without imagination, perception is limited. VIII. Limited Perception The imagination does not belong to the body nor the soul; only the mind. Descartes believes that if he imagines something; either during wake or sleep, he is essentially exiting his body and becoming something that is no longer part of his corporal self. Descartes realizes that it’s through the body that we use our five senses which are clearly known. The sense of touch, smell, hearing, sight, and taste are all properties which allow us to feel real. Humans create the senses and impress the properties of those senses on objects. He believes that when wax is put near the fire, it loses or changes its properties allowing the senses of humans to be altered. The alteration does not equal elimination of the essence of the wax, but a change has been made and now the human needs to adapt to the new “wax”. The change is not made through the senses but instead, through one’s cognition. IX. Cognition What Descartes knows to be true, and what he imagines through his senses creates an argument. This argument is the differences between the mind and the body. What he knows to be true is different than what is actually true. Truth, in its essence is relative. The idea of the wax keeping its essential state is a faculty of imagination. One cannot even begin to imagine what the wax is after it has been changed. One however, can create lucid thoughts of what they think the wax could be. This, in theory is difficult to comprehend due to its relativism. In light of the changing states, adaptation is needed to better comprehend the complexity of what is going on. Descartes states that in the end, it’s still wax. He holds that the faculty of judgment allows for humans to create and destroy their own existence and perceive truth in ways that is more complex, stimulating and mind boggling. Descartes’ ability to create an argument for himself, and question his very existence is in fact the crux of the changing properties of a piece of wax. X. Conclusion In conclusion, Descartes’ ability to be introspective allows for his arguments to be evaluated and valued. The argument he creates makes the path straight for those who are looking for answers regarding the faculties he mentions. The faculty of judgment along with imagination is really Descartes main focus. The idea that a piece of wax is just a piece of wax becomes obsolete if the faculties at hand are not considered. Judgment and imagination are Descartes’ faculties which lead him to believe that a piece of wax will always be a piece of wax, even in the eyes of its changing properties. WORK CITED Steiner, Rudolf. Rel. Authors. 11 8 2008. 2 2 2012 . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Descartes - A Piece of Wax Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Descartes - A Piece of Wax Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1442206-descartes-a-piece-of-wax
(Descartes - A Piece of Wax Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Descartes - A Piece of Wax Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1442206-descartes-a-piece-of-wax.
“Descartes - A Piece of Wax Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1442206-descartes-a-piece-of-wax.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Piece of Wax by Descartes

Dependability of Science Based on Empiricism

In the wax example, Descartes further demonstrates the unreliability of the senses by claiming that a piece of wax in its solid form will look, feel and smell very differently from itself if it were melted.... The focus of the paper "Modern Philosophy" is on descartes's argument, mind and body to bond, descartes Cartesian dualism, assumption, instructor Date From antiquity to contemporary times, Rene descartes, a critical factor that emerges, from antiquity to contemporary times....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Mind and Body as Conceived by Descartes and Pascal

The focus of the paper "Mind and Body as Conceived by descartes and Pascal" is on Rene Descartes, the basic breadth of the mind-body debate, Descartes's demise, Cartesian dualism, Plato and Aristotle, Cartesian dualism, the mind and the body, theories about the mind and the body.... he differences between descartes and Pascal are vast, mainly because Pascal was first and foremost in his heart a scientist.... descartes was at his core, however, a thinker-a logician of the highest quality....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Descartes Third Meditation: Proving the Existence of God

Each piece of evidence states that an identified effect can be clarified as long as an all-powerful being is present.... The focus of the paper "descartes' Third Meditation: Proving the Existence of God" is on the Third Meditation, God's existence, method of doubt, the arguments of descartes, his evidence or 'proof', several central realities about the universe, the dilemmas simultaneously.... hellip; The premise of descartes in the Third Meditation on the existence of God is a form of a cosmological premise, progressing from a conditional basis about what exists to the final assumption that this is not likely to exist if not were 'caused to exist by God'....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Rene Descartes Discourse

It contains the revolutionary ideas presented by descartes that ultimately shaped the face of not… Essentially, Descartes' philosophical dispersion among his autobiographical recount in Discourse argues that there is a truth to be reached in this world and that truth may only be reached if one establishes Rene Descartes was a Frenchman who was born to a wealthy family in Touraine in 1596 CITATION Des08 \l 1033 .... The philosophical and autobiographical treatise, “Discourse on the Method” by Rene descartes is one of the most important pieces of literature in the field of modern philosophy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Descartes: Mind over Body

In this context, using his example of the piece of wax, Descartes succeeds in his argument that true judgment depends on the strength of the intellect.... This essay "descartes: Mind over Body" has a goal of explaining the key features of the philosopher's work and outlook on things.... descartes spent the major part of his life in the Netherlands and moved to Sweden in 1649, where he died of pneumonia the following year, on February 11.... n 1641, descartes published in Latin, and later in French, his Meditationes de prima Philosophia (Meditations on First Philosophy), which is arguably his most popular work in contemporary times....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Mind and Body as Conceived by Descartes and Pascal

This work called "Mind and Body as Conceived by descartes and Pascal" describes the relationship between mind and body as conceived by any two or all three of Descartes and Pascal.... nbsp;This idea does not make a lot of logical sense at first glance, nevertheless, this was descartes's legacy.... he differences between descartes and Pascal are vast, mainly because Pascal was first and foremost in his heart a scientist.... descartes was at his core, however, a thinker—a logician of the highest quality....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Descartes' Wax Argument

How the mind observes things, why doubt is created, how perception and relativity changes with time, what expression looks like, how the mind, body and soul function as a unit, and how a limited perception affect cognition can be explained by descartes through is an argument of judgment and imagination.... From the paper "descartes' Wax Argument" it is clear that descartes' ability to be introspective allows for his arguments to be evaluated and valued....
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review

Philosophy by Nietzsche and Kant

This perception leads descartes' to present that notion of the existence of God.... descartes refers to God as an infinite being in his letters to Island dated 2nd May 1644.... descartes' uses his judgment of infinity to try to reinforce and prove the perception that there is God.... descartes' uses what is normal in reality to explain the perception of God and change the judgment of his audience that there is God by defining using infinity....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us