StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

An Analysis on the Design Phase of Euro Shuttle Wagons Project - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This study focuses on the development issue of Euro channel tunnel wagons to give an insight on raising project management issues, and to come up with possible solutions, and to suggest possible project management structure and theories to decrease associated risks in the project…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.1% of users find it useful
An Analysis on the Design Phase of Euro Shuttle Wagons Project
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "An Analysis on the Design Phase of Euro Shuttle Wagons Project"

An Analysis on the Design Phase of Euro Shuttle Wagons Project Executive summary Channel tunnel shuttle service is a means of transport by rail through the channel tunnel. The process of building shuttle wagons carries different development phases and associated risk, design phase of a Tunnel project faces tight time scale and heavy liquidated damages associated with delays, therefore efficiency and consideration of all elements in each phase is very important. There are different cases reflecting inefficiencies in the development processes of above discussed projects, of which one is ‘Eurotunnel shuttle wagons case’, this case focuses on design and manufacturing phase of Eurotunnel shuttle wagons. Euro tunnel had contracted TransManche Link (TML) to build the Channel Tunnel, and TML had subcontracted the manufacturing of Shuttle wagons to rolling-stock manufacturers, with transferring of building task ultimately to rolling-stock manufactures risk of tight time scale and heavy liquidated damages (LDs) is also transferred to them. The objective of this study is to analyse and work on inefficiencies of development process of above discussed Euro tunnel wagons project. There are number of inefficiencies have been seen in the design process; initially safety clause were ill-defined and only considered gradually, this shows that there were some design parameters which were firstly not defined. Another design flaw intergovernmental commission raised was poorly designed wagons to carry heavy goods vehicle. Changes required by the intergovernmental commission may not only cause time-delays but it may also required changes in other elements due to ripple effect. So the risks identified in this project are time delays, risk of cost efficiencies, risk of pay back of borrowing on time, risk of disruption on design schedule and risk of disturbance in further production processes. Reasons identified in lack of efficiencies are project scope which was not clearly defined, poor planning, poorly designed design parameters, and lack of proper communication between active parties. There are number of project management techniques could have been reduced the rising risk and issues but unfortunately no measures were taken. Introduction This study focuses on the development issue of Euro channel tunnel wagons to give an insight on rising project management issues; and to come up with possible solutions, and to suggest possible project management structure and theories to decrease associated risks in the project. Therefore, the purpose of the study is to analyse flaws of project development phase and to suggest structures and methodologies that could and should have been used. The report will provide background of the project to better understand the situation; then it will address design and manufacturing flaws in Euro channel tunnel wagons project, which is contracted to TransManche Link (TML) to build the Channel Tunnel, and subcontracted to build shuttle wagons to rolling-stock manufacturers; then it will propose project management theories and structure that should have been used to minimise the project risk with analysis; and then it will discuss key findings of the report. Project background Euro tunnel shuttle service is a shuttle transport service that expresses street vehicle by rail through the channel tunnel. The wagons used for the shuttle have a large loading capacity; and it has a separate space for passengers, and freight vehicles. Eurotunnel had contracted TransManche Link (TML) to construct the Channel Tunnel, and TML had subcontracted a group of rolling-stock manufacturers to build the Shuttle Wagons. The Tunnel project usually has a very tight timescale and heavy liquidated damages (LDs) linked with delays and so this one. Eurotunnel’s success rate is dependent on the timeframe of tunnel being finished and ready to start its operations in particular season, otherwise interest payments would start to devastate the profit of the project. There are many aspects of design, construction and operation of the Euro Channel Tunnel Wagons project that needs approval from the Intergovernmental Commission (IGC), a body of British and French civil servants. The main focus of project manager during development phase of the project is and should be on safety, defence, security and environmental issues, as IGC takes these issues as criteria to evaluate the performance of channel tunnel project. The safety clause was not clearly defined at the start of the project and was later gradually defined; this was not only because of the unfamiliarity of tunnel channel to safety regulators, but also because of the allegation of events such as the UK Kings Cross Fire in November 1987. Due to lack of safety, changes are required to meet IGC considerations and the effect of those changes was not only delays but it also had impacted on other related elements of the project and characteristics of the product, and on the image of TML. These effects have forced management to either to complete design tasks in a complex parallel way than a usual systematic way or two concentrate on elements for which environment has not yet frozen. To complete the additional work resulted from redesigning of activities, additional workers were hired and training of those workers by in-house managers shifted their focus from designing to training and due to eventual shortage of specialised engineers many unspecialised engineers were also hired. Identification of project management related issues and risks Lack of defined design parameters from the beginning has decreased the chances of achieving milestone and project success. The major issue of the design phase of this project is safety issue which has created project risk of attaining desirable outcome at given time scale and to meet obligations. Time delayed factor due to redesigning has created schedule risk Redesigning of activities in the Tunnel Channel project has required re-performance of many tasks and recruitment of many extra workers to finish the project on time which has created cost risk Redesign caused disturbance in the design schedule which has affected other sub activities of the project, thus increasing project implementation complexities and has evolved control risk. Heavy liquidity damages by the delay of project have seemed to minimise project profit over interest. Purposed Work breakdown structure Stake holders and their criteria of success or failure Euro tunnel shuttle authority, it is the authority is responsible for all tunnel services; it is the one who decided to build the euro tunnel shuttle wagons. The criteria of success for euro tunnel shuttle authority is the implementation of the project on time which it has recommended, and if fails timely implementation or find any technological fault in wagons on later stage of implementation than it considers it a project failure. TransManche Link (TML) is a contractor to build the Channel Tunnel. For euro tunnel, TML is responsible for building the euro tunnel shuttle wagons so the success criteria for TML is timely completion of the project; if the project fails to meet time-lines than it is a project failure for them. Group of rolling-stock manufacturers is a subcontractor to build shuttle wagons. Group of rolling-stock manufacturers are the one who is ultimately responsible for the creation of shuttle wagons therefore their success criteria is most crucial, timely completion with no involvement of additional cost and resources with minimum technical risk in the design and production process is the success criteria for them, while lacking of any success criteria may lead to project failure for them. End users are the stakeholders which are the passengers in this case, who uses the tunnel wagon service. For passengers, success criteria of this project are safety, comfort and ease in travelling. If the passengers find the project unsafe, discomfort and no timely arrivals then they considered it project failure. Discussion and analysis There are number of risks associated with this study, which have been discussed earlier under the heading of Identification of project management related issues and risks. These risks could/should be recognised and managed by risk management technique of project management which aims in identifying and minimising all possible risks associated with undertaken project, it is a proactive approach rather than reactive and it improves chances of achieving goals within given time and budget. As discussed earlier associated risks with this project are control risk, project risk, schedule risk, and cost risk that could be easily managed by the practice of this technique. There are several issues which seemed to be connected in this study such as design flaw resulted in redoing of activities which has incurred additional cost and delays in the process therefore there is a need of classification of possible risk associated with different development phases and activities, for that risk break down structure should have been adopted by the manufacturers to better manage the risk. The likely hood of occurrence of above discussed risks could be known through risk assessment form which could ease the risk detection and process. Design flaws has created many issues in this study which could have been mitigate through the presence of alternate or contingency plan as this plan could have reduced the associated cost and liquidity damages. Conclusion To conclude, there have been different issues sighted in the development of shuttle wagon project, which are related to design process of Euro tunnel shuttle wagons. They include design flaws which have raised safety issues and ease issues in freight compartment, which have been followed by redesigning cost and time delays. To overcome these issues number of project management techniques have been suggested, it includes risk management technique, risk break down structure, use of risk assessment form and contingency plan. Successful implantation of these techniques could have lessened the risk of project failure. Bibliography Atkinson, R. (1999). Project management: cost, time and quality, two best guesses and a phenomenon, it’s time to accept other success criteria. International Journal of Project Management, 17(6), 337-342. Burke, R. (1999). Project management: planning and control techniques. England: John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Haugan, G. (2002). Work Breakdown Structures. Vienna, VA: Management Concepts, Inc. Kerzner, H. (2006). Project management: a systems approach to planning, scheduling, and controlling. NJ: John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Kerzner, H. (2009). Project management case studies. NJ: John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Kerzner, H. (2010). Project Management Best Practices: achieving global excellence. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons. Lock, D. (2007). Project Management. Hampshire, England: Gower Publishing company. Miller, D. (2008). Building a Project Work Breakdown Structure: visualizing objectives, deliverables, activities, and schedules. New York: Taylor and Francis. Milosevic, D. (2003). Project Management Toolbox: tools and techniques for the practicing project manager. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons. Pinto, J, & Slevin, D. (1988b). Project success: definitions and measurement techniques. Project Management Journal, vol. 19, no. 1, pp. 67-72. Pinto, J, and Slevin, D. (1988a). Critical success factors across the project life cycle. Project Management Journal , vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 67-75. Taylor, J. (2008). Project Scheduling and Cost Control: planning, monitoring, and controlling the baseline. Florida: J. Ross Publishing Inc. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“An Analysis on the Design Phase of Euro Shuttle Wagons Project Essay”, n.d.)
An Analysis on the Design Phase of Euro Shuttle Wagons Project Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1596453-an-analysis-on-the-design-phase-of-euro-shuttle-wagons-project
(An Analysis on the Design Phase of Euro Shuttle Wagons Project Essay)
An Analysis on the Design Phase of Euro Shuttle Wagons Project Essay. https://studentshare.org/management/1596453-an-analysis-on-the-design-phase-of-euro-shuttle-wagons-project.
“An Analysis on the Design Phase of Euro Shuttle Wagons Project Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1596453-an-analysis-on-the-design-phase-of-euro-shuttle-wagons-project.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF An Analysis on the Design Phase of Euro Shuttle Wagons Project

Analysis report of Shuttle Wagons project

Analysis Report of shuttle wagons project [Supervisor Name] Executive Summary The success of Shuttle Wagon Project was largely dependent on the in time completion of the tunnel.... Analysis Report of shuttle wagons project Purpose of the Report The task of constructing the shuttle wagons was given to Trans Manche Link who subcontracted other manufacturers to build the wagons.... But there were a number of problems which continued to roll up, there were design issues of the shuttle wagons, the entire operation required permission from the Inter Governmental Commission and the shuttles were called back for safety reasons....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Shuttle Wagons Project Plan

shuttle wagons” Project Plan Name: Institution: Table of contents Page Introduction …………………………………………………………………………………3 Project background ………………………………………………………………………….... “shuttle wagons” PROJECT PLAN Introduction The Channel Tunnel project incorporates a three-bore tunnel construction.... TML then subcontracted different roll shock manufactures for the buildings of the shuttle wagons....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Channel Tunnel Project

In the context of its development process the project was simply divided into the design phase, manufacturing phase and testing phase.... Eurotunnel has contracted the project to Transmachine Link (TML) that has again sub contracted other manufacturers for manufacturing the shuttle wagons.... project Management Executive Summary The channel tunnel project is considered as the biggest engineering project in the history of mankind....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Project Management of the Channel Tunnel

This is very much reflected in the case of shuttle wagons of channel tunnels that connects United Kingdom with France.... This is very much reflected in the case of shuttle wagons of channel tunnels that connects United Kingdom with France.... But the work got delayed due to the design problems of the shuttle wagons.... The channel tunnel comprised of two tunnels for shuttle wagons and in between these two tunnels there is a path or road mainly used for surveillance....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Human Rights, Law and Police Ethics in Ireland and India

The purpose of this Paper is to carry out a comparative analysis of securing human rights through Law and their protection through the Police Force in the Republic of Ireland and the Republic of India.... India is compared to Ireland in these respects because there is a good amount of similarities between these countries and also a great deal of differences between them....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

The Three Important Learnings Relating to Project Management

We will look at two real projects that the mentioned have discussed in comparison to project management theories.... Hasan Yahya, defines project management as “the discipline of planning, organizing and managing resources to bring about the successful completion of specific project goals and objectives”.... It is this discipline that we particularly look at in this paper through the lenses of project management experts....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Brand Strategy of Gucci

This study includes an analysis of sex as communication and marketing strategy.... hellip; The author states that the integrity of the Gucci design is traced back to a solid work ethics and entrepreneurial values of Guccio Gucci of Italy, who, early in his career, realised the importance of building a name and reputation, and thus stamped the Gucci identifier on selected editions of his leather luggage for high-end hotel guests.... The Gucci spirit, which is essentially a passion for a vibrant lifestyle, is kept alive by succeeding generations of creative designers, the more remarkable of whom was the American Tom Ford, noted for his strategic use of sex in design and advertising and currently, the Italian Frida Giannini, who understands best the wants and needs of a Gucci woman....
39 Pages (9750 words) Dissertation

Logo Design as Corporate Identity Tool in High Fashion Industry

The author of the current coursework "Logo design as Corporate Identity Tool in High Fashion Industry" states that every business organization is in a constant quest for a discreet corporate identity that should be reflected in its products, services and in its look culture.... Thus the importance of a logo design.... Claudia Winifred in her Research has revealed that a good logo design strives to put as many visual messages is the logo as possible....
34 Pages (8500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us