StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ethical Issues in Criminology - Assignment Example

Summary
The paper "Ethical Issues in Criminology" highlights that research on criminological activities involves observation of ethical issues which affect both the participants and the community. These are concerns that determine the success of the research and the quality of the findings…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Ethical Issues in Criminology"

Critical Evaluation Student`s Name Professor Institution Date of Submission Ethical Issues in Criminology According to Israel (2005), there are four main ethical issues in criminology that confronts social scientists. These issues includes: informed consent, confidentiality, various relationships, and harms and benefits. Even though some of these issues confront criminologists, the same issues also affect anthropologists, sociologists, educational researchers, psychologists and qualitative health researchers. Most of these ethical issues that these other researchers occasionally face are day to day ethical issues faced by criminological researchers. Bachman and Schutt (2012) explained that these issues relate to the sensitivity of the subject matter, susceptibility of those involved in the research, the attitudes of crime offenders’ institutions towards such research and the powerful positions that some state and corporate bodies hold which make it difficult to conduct research on them. They further pointed out that some of these positions make it hard to investigate the conduct of these officials because the complexity of their work. These issues pose major problems to the researchers because they determine the quality and accuracy of the research. Research case study 1 “You have obtained a research grant to interview a sample of 50 young men (aged 14 to 18 years) about their experiences and attitudes to violence, both as perpetrators and as victims. The face-to-face interviews will be conducted at a variety of locations, including the homes of the young men. During the research, many of the young men revealed that they had committed violent acts, including four young men who informed the interviewers that they had been involved in homicides. In many cases, the young men had not been arrested for their violence, including those who had revealed involvement in homicide”. In the first case study, an important ethical issue that emerges is confidentiality. This is brought about by the fact that the research is conducted on young men who are aged between 14 and 18 years. This means that there were definitely a number of interviewees who did not understand the possible risks and benefits which come with revealing such information. From the study, it can also be seen that most of the respondents were concerned with the confidentiality of the information they were giving. This is brought out by the fact that there might have been more than four respondents who had been involved in homicides but they could not reveal the sensitive information to the researcher due to confidentiality issues. According to a study by Webb (2008), conducting research on juvenile offenders is likely to raise more confidentiality concerns mainly on accountability and community interests. The fact that the research in case study one was conducted through face-to-face interviews brings about privacy issues among the respondents. This is because some respondents can not be willing to share their life experiences especially those about their criminal records with strangers through interviews. Other methods of data collection such as telephone interviews or questionnaires would have been more appropriate because the respondents would have been more confident and hence provide more accurate results. Most of the respondents within the age bracket of 14 and 18 may not be in a position to understand the National Statement requirements and hence end up providing information without their full knowledge. This is because the National Statement states that the researcher must obtain the voluntary and informed consent of the participants. Prior information should be provided by the researcher so that the participants will be well informed of the requirements and importance of the research (Isreal, 2004). This will ensure that the respondents are aware of the requirements and implications that may arise from the information they provided. Consequently they will give information on their own will and consent and hence improve the accuracy and quality of the research findings. Another ethical issue evident in case study one is that of the harms and benefits. The researcher does not take into consideration the possible harms that may happen to the respondents because there are no measures in place to minimise risk which may occur to them. However, the researcher aims at benefiting the society from the finding of the study. This is because of the sensitive issue on criminology which involves serious crimes such as homicides and violence acts. These are critical crimes which affect the whole society and should be handled with the care they deserve. Research case study 2 “As you are interested in alcohol, drugs and violence, you get a part-time job as a bouncer at a local club. After working there for three months, you decide to conduct a research project on the expression of violence in clubs. To do this, during your shifts, you start taking notes covertly about the behaviour of patrons at the club. In some shifts, you yourself become involved in violent incidents as part of your role as a bouncer”. In case study two, the researcher who apparently happens to be the bouncer in the local club decides to conduct research on alcohol, drugs and violence. However, the researcher has no permission from the authorities to carry out the research. This is in line with the National Statement which states that the researcher should have the consent of the participants to conduct the research on them and the use of the information obtained. The research was also conducted without the informed consent of the respondents. This is because researchers must inform the interviewees of the research being conducted, its benefits, the risks as well as the discomfort of interview (Maxfield & Babbie, 2010). This is because of the possibility that a participant in the research may find it difficult to accept to take part in the research due to being labelled by the justice system. Consequently the intended purpose of the research may not be realised because the participant may be forced to hold back potential harmful information. It is also evident that in the second case the respondent obtained data with no consent of the informant. This also contravenes the National Statement requirements that require voluntary consent of the participants in the research. Maxfield & Babbie (2010) argued that this is because according to the principle of informed consent participants in the research should know the implications that come with being involved in the research. The National Statement further states that participants may be provided with a list of their entitlements and information which they can choose to request from the researcher. The harms and benefits issue is also witnessed in this case study where the researcher is concerned with the harms that the participants may cause to the society. Issues of drugs, alcohol and violence are being investigated in the research and its findings will be of benefit to the society or criminal justice institutions. These issues are important ethical concerns in conducting research on criminology because of the sensitive nature of the research. Criminological research involves serious crimes such as corruption, homicide, drugs, violence and murder, among others. Eliciting of such sensitive information might disturb the participants and the society, hence makes the matter important ethical issue. Maxfield and Babbie (2010) also argued that conflicts of interest may arise from carrying out such research. Conflicts of interest for research researchers in this field are likely to occur from gaining of such detailed information. These issues are also of great concert in criminological research because of the confidentiality and possible subpoena which might arise in the handling and use of research findings. This is brought about by the need to have strategies to use in order to deal with possibility of subpoena. These include adoption of methodological measures and legal strategy. If the research was conducted on the experiences and attitudes of police officers to violence, the above ethical issues would not change. This is because similar crimes are being investigated and the possible involvement of the police officers in crimes. Police officers may not be free with the researchers due to confidentiality issues for fear of being victimised by their seniors (Mazerolle, Anrobus, Bennett & Tyler, 2013). The research would be of benefit to the society because the findings would be useful in monitoring crimes in the society. The respondents are law enforcers and hence would ensure that they follow informed-consent rules hence will be aware of the risks and benefits associated with the interview. The position that the police hold can also hinder efficient interview affecting the carrying out of the research. If the researcher was standing in the street at night conducting the research, similar ethical issues would be of concern again. This is because the information would be collected without the consent of the respondents contrary to the National Statement requirements. The researcher has an obligation to submit the report of the findings, a move which will compromise the desires of their funding agency. There are also confidentiality issues which require the respondents to provide criminal and other relevant subversive activity. This means that conducting such research would still have ethical concerns that need to be addressed. In conclusion, research on criminological activities involves observation of ethical issues which affect both the participants and the community. These are concerns which determine the success of the research and quality of the findings. The use of interviews requires that the researcher briefs respondents on the possible benefits and harm which may arise from giving out their information. It is therefore, important to consider the ethical concerns while carrying out research especially on criminology. References Bachman, R. & Schutt, R. (2012). Fundamentals of Research in Criminology and Criminal Justice, (2nd Ed). New York; NY: SAGE Publications, Inc Isreal, M. (2004). Ethics and the Governance of Criminological Research in Australia. Sydney: NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research. Maxfield, G. & Babbie, E. (2010). Research Methods for Criminal Justice and Criminology. Cambridge, CA: Cengage Learning. Mazerolle, L., Anrobus, E., Bennett, S., Tyler, T. (2013). Shaping Citizen Perceptions of Police Legitimacy: A Randomized Field Trial of Procedural Justice. Criminology 51(1):33-63 Webb, P. (2008). Privacy or publicity: Media coverage and juvenile justice proceedings in the United States. International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, 3(1), 1-14. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical Issues in Criminology

Criminology in relation to violence in protests

Moreover, the field sociology and behavioral sciences is one that is very effective in ensuring that the concepts and issues brought up in criminology are in a civil and more conventional manner.... The researcher of this paper takes a glance at the criminology in relation to violence in protests.... The various theories of criminology show the value of criminology in comprehending the issue of protests, whether violent or non-violent....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Ethical Issues and the Use of Force

ethical issues and the Use of Force A problem or issue statement and Research questions From time immemorial, the activities of human have bordered both in the positive direction as well as in the negative direction.... So, this paper will focus on the above discussed issues, which surround and concern the ethical use of force.... In addition to these guidelines, the authorities are given access to many technological tools, so they use force in an apt and ethical manner....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Ethical Principles in Research

The report summarizes the primary ethical principles and guidelines that should help in the process of determining the ethical issues.... The issues are mainly related with the people who are responsible for carrying out the research.... Ethics Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Introduction 3 History of ethical Principles in Research 3 Belmont Report 4 Regulations and Social and Behavioral Sciences 4 Assessing Risk in Social and Behavioral Science 5 Informed Consent 5 Privacy and Confidentiality 5 Data Collection 5 Conflict of Interest in Research 6 Conclusion 6 References 7 7 Introduction Ethics is the way of perceiving what is right and what is wrong (McLaughlin and Muncie 354)....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Ethics and Ethical Behavior

The "Ethics and ethical Behavior" paper discusses ethics and ethical behavior in police integrity and the impacts of these factors on the police force, the citizenry, and the justice system of a country.... Moral and ethical values should be the guiding principles behind police work, which makes the difference between a police officer and a citizen.... Thus, this means that police work should be guided by ethical practices and moral considerations that reflect what is enshrined in the law and justice that police work serves....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Criminology: Understanding Social Learning Theory

Understanding social learning theory in criminology can be simple or complex, but this depends on the relationships made by social scientists in formulating theories (Akers 56).... This theory argues that “as social creatures, our behavior is a product of our environment,” thus understanding social learning theory is imperative because it enables the policy makers to implement effective strategies for combating crime issues in the society.... criminology is the scientific study that involves the nature and cause of the crime as well as control of criminal behaviors through imposing laws or regulations in the society....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Issues In Police Ethics

On this basis, this paper analyzes the legal and ethical issues that arise when police officers look out for their colleagues.... This paper has managed to highlight the ethical and legal issues that members of the police force face when they are looking out for their colleagues.... This paper denotes that mistrust emanating from the public, and loyalty amongst police officers are some of the major issues that arise when police office breach their codes of ethics....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Deontology Security Administration and Capital Equity Investigate

ethical issues are authoritative in considering different courses of action, and as a potential for targeting criminal justices.... Unfortunately, criminal justice and criminology research involves dealing with humans and human behavior that is guided by ethics (Jones & Bartlett, 2008).... However, when carrying out such research, several concerns have to come in such as:It is, therefore, necessary that a researcher carrying out the research understand what is meant by ethics and its importance on criminology researches....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Ethical Issues in Criminal Justice

This paper "ethical issues in Criminal Justice" mainly deals with analyzing the importance of addressing and mitigating the ethical issues that are involved in the process of executing criminal justice-based activities, in particular criminal penalties.... It is worth mentioning in this concern that the aspect of ethics is quite vital in the domain of criminal justice wherein scenarios arise for the judges or lawyers to deal with varied ethical dilemmas.... Notably, police or other legal authorities usually try to serve the best interests of the people for which they often need to take harsh or strict decisions that further raise moral or ethical concerns at large....
12 Pages (3000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us