StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analyses: Sycamore Pharmaceuticals and The Boy, The Girl, the Ferryboat Captain, and the Hermits - Case Study Example

Summary
"Case Analyses: Sycamore Pharmaceuticals and The Boy, The Girl, the Ferryboat Captain, and the Hermits" paper analizes the case that was all about the upcoming backlash against the Sycamore Pharmaceuticals after proceeding to market its Osteoporin product with full knowledge that its effectiveness is obscure…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
Case Analyses: Sycamore Pharmaceuticals and The Boy, The Girl, the Ferryboat Captain, and the Hermits
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analyses: Sycamore Pharmaceuticals and The Boy, The Girl, the Ferryboat Captain, and the Hermits"

5 March Case Analyses: “Sycamore Pharmaceuticals” and “The Boy, The Girl, the Ferryboat Captain, and the Hermits” Sycamore Pharmaceuticals The case was all about the upcoming backlash against the Sycamore Pharmaceuticals after proceeding to market its Osteoporin product with full knowledge that its effectiveness is obscure. The discovery about its effectivity was unearthed and disseminated through a CNN report. The rest of the case detailed the exchange between the two employees of Sycamore’s communications department, Cole Dominguez and John Blake. Apart from their discourse about the company’s culpability in the Osteoporin, circumstances supporting their reasons for participating and apparently ignoring their corporate social responsibility or CSR were revealed -- the bonus. In response to the nearing onslaught, the company instead wore a defensive mechanism: instilling ‘commitment’ (in the company’s blog statement) and insisting Osteoporin’s effectiveness through an “illusion” (Daft and Lane 189). The dilemma then sits in the afternoon interview with the FDA representative; Blake’s conflicting thoughts continuously plagued him (Daft and Lane 190). An Advise. I would advise Blake to spill the truth. He himself recognized and admitted what was wrong: “We knew we were taking a risk, Cole ...” (Daft and Lane 189). The repetitive dereference in this statement through the pronoun, ‘we,’ is a form of responsible admission. Apparently, Blake and the company were given the chance to correct this breach they just did. All Blake had to do was reveal the truth and his guilt, which was captured through this statement: “This just feels so wrong,” can somehow be driven out (Daft and Lane 190). Being honest with the FDA have several pros and cons to offer. However, depending with one’s perspective, the pros seemed to outweigh whatever cons it has. The cons may include, but are not limited to, (1) no quarter bonus; (2) demotion; and (3) dismissal (Daft and Lane 190). On the other hand, the pros involved here can be described collectively as the ‘opportunity to start with a cleaner slate.’ Blake can somehow clear his name through the admission of his participation. Otherwise, he and his resumé will forever be tainted and associated with Sycamore’s Osteoporin fiasco. Moreover, choosing to tell the truth and act as a witness usually lessens the sanctions. Otherwise, with Osteoporin’s obscure effectivity and the likelihood of being proven guilty, sanctions will be relatively heavier than those of the witness. Lastly, the bonus is not even sustainable if it was based on falsifying and other bad practices. With the company’s penchant for deception, big bonuses seemed analogous to losing both sleep and peace of mind. Courage. Indeed, it would require Blake all of the courage he has to reveal the details of the Osteoporin fiasco. Evidently, it was never easy to admit the wrong things one committed. However, to help Blake muster enough courage to spill, he may look and solicit the assistance of another trusted person, who unlike him, have no potential for any conflicts of interest. He may also talk with a lawyer specializing in such matters; maybe, knowledge of what sanctions are waiting for the company and him (in relation to his participation) may make him think twice about lying. Going Along. The possible reasons behind Dominguez and Blake’s participation include (1) the fact that the CEO and the top management ‘ordered’ them to do so; (2) the big bonus; and (3) risks regarding their positions (fired or demotion). If I were them, I would not participate (and resign before they could fire me). Participating in such deception will not just taint my personality but my resumé, as well. The Boy, The Girl, the Ferryboat Captain, and the Hermits The case was much about the journey of a girl from her island to the boy’s island. To reach her destination she was proffered two options: the first option, and the easiest, was to cancel the journey and not see the boy; the second was to sacrifice herself (to the ferryboat captain) and be able to see the boy. While the former option was hardly an option, the latter entailed a great sacrifice (in the girl’s perspective). Then facing the boy’s rejection of her, after the ‘sacrifice’ was made known, she had to think of a way to go back to her island. The accountable reason why she had to face these misadventures was her lack of the fare required to make such journey. Moreover, her adventures were marked by the ‘participation’ of two hermits. Character’s values. I most like the girl and the second hermit (of the boy’s island), and I least like the first hermit (of the girl’s island), the ferryboat captain, and the boy. The values that governed my choice of ‘likes’ are courage and compassion. The girl had been courageous to make the journey and defile herself ‘in the name of love’ while the second hermit exhibited such compassion to the girl. Moral development. Both the girl and the second hermit have a higher level of moral development. The girl recognized the moral wrong of offering herself as payment, yet she knew what mattered most for her and was willing to defy this moral wrong. The second hermit’s moral maturity was marked by the fact that he did not take advantage of the girl’s distress and, instead, extended his hand to help her. The characters -- the first hermit, the ferryboat captain, and the boy, all have a poor level of moral development. Unlike the second hermit, the first hermit failed to ‘intervene’ and wash herself of the girl’s indecision. On the other hand, the ferryboat captain proceeded to take advantage of the girl’s distress while the boy was the opposite of the girl. While the girl was courageous, the boy was coward; he was too coward to accept the defiled girl who, at the first place, chose to defile herself for him. Courage. The girl had the highest level of courage, and next to her was the second hermit. As aforementioned, she was courageous to face and conquer the unknown in lieu of her seeing the boy. The second hermit was not scared of intervening and offered all that he could offer (shelter, food, bed) as well as take an extra effort by begging money for the girl’s fare (Daft and Lane 191). The second hermit, ferryboat captain, and boy have the lowest levels of courage. The second hermit was too scared to ‘intervene’ or help the girl while the ferryboat captain had no scruples and was not scared to be held accountable of doing such abominable acts (as taking a girl’s body in exchange of the fare). As aforementioned, the boy did not have the courage to be associated to a defiled girl (even if the girl was defiled only to see him). Work Cited Daft, Richard L., and Patricia G. Lane. The Leadership Experience. 5th ed. Mason, OH: Cengage Learning, 2010. Print. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Case Analyses: Sycamore Pharmaceuticals and The Boy, The Girl, the Ferryboat Captain, and the Hermits

Teva Pharmaceuticals: Case Analyisis

Teva pharmaceuticals: Case Analysis 1.... It is evident from the case analysis that innovative product lines are the most potential resources/capabilities of the Teva pharmaceuticals Industries Ltd according to VRINE criteria.... Potential employee groups are other potential resources of Teva pharmaceuticals.... In order to assess the long term sustainability of Teva pharmaceuticals, it would be better to analyze the company using the Porter's Five Forces model....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Corporate Social Responsibility of Merck Pharmaceuticals

It should be reminded that Merck Pharmaceuticals is one of the biggest global pharmaceuticals and profitability could be staggering to ordinary people.... From the paper "Corporate Social Responsibility of Merck pharmaceuticals" it is clear that Merck pharmaceuticals should embrace a holistic approach in its business process and operations to encompass environmental and community programs, as well as public accountability.... Ley     Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) of Merck pharmaceuticals   A) CSR  Wood (1991) defined corporate social responsibility (CSR) as a corporate self-regulation and integral part of the business process in compliance with ethical standards....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Analysis of Pharmaceutical Industry

80 Percent of the research and development in pharmaceuticals is conducted in the laboratories of USA (Select USA, 2013).... In the UK the pharmaceuticals industry is regarded to be the most profitable sector after Finance and Tourism.... Majority of the pharmaceutical company's revenue is generated from the USA because it is the world's largest free pricing market for pharmaceuticals....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Young Leaders Council Analysis

??The Boy, The Girl, The Ferryboat Captain, and the hermits” ... y opinion to The Boy, The Girl, The Ferryboat Captain, and the hermits case study ... The character I disliked the most was the ferryboat captain.... The character with the least moral standards was the ferryboat captain.... The least courage of all characters is illustrated in the character of the ferryboat captain.... She was desperate and the ferryboat captain took advantage of the situation....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Marketing Innovation in Roche Pharmaceuticals

Roche is a globally renowned producer of medical equipment, taking the divisions of pharmaceuticals and diagnostics respectively (Tinguely, 2013, p.... Therefore, Roche should adapt new strategies that will enable its marketing innovation programs to serve for the benefit of pharmaceuticals and diagnostics with equated urgency.... hadlen, K, C, Guennif, S, and Chavez, AG 2011, Intellectual Property, pharmaceuticals and Public Health Access To Drugs In Developing Countries, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar Pub....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

Strategic Management: Hikma Pharmaceuticals Plc

This paper aims at understanding the strategic gap of a well-known multinational pharmaceutical company, Hikma pharmaceuticals and accordingly generates strategic recommendations so that the company can evolve as one of the best companies in global pharmaceutical industry.... he prevailing social background of MENA region, United States and North America enhances the scope of operation for Hikma pharmaceuticals and company in turn returns the favour to the society through employment generation and confirming employee well being....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Analysis of Pharmaceutical Issues

pharmaceuticals ... The World health organization plays an important role in terms of the classification of the pharmaceuticals in the world.... The Classes of pharmaceuticals ... The numbers of pharmaceuticals firms are also on the increase for the purposes of satisfying the market demand.... However, Canada is also considered as one of the largest producer of pharmaceuticals in the world.... "analyses related to the development of DSM-5 criteria for substance use related disorders: 1....
19 Pages (4750 words) Report

Business Analysis of Home Pharmaceuticals

"Business Analysis of Home pharmaceuticals " paper focuses on Home pharmaceutical that is situated in Malaysia and is founded upon the culture of research and puts in emphasis in producing OTC drugs and over the years it has ventured into new products such as bio-medical and food supplements.... The industry for Home pharmaceuticals could be described as technology-intensive where research and development are carried out and has the potential for innovation and contribute to national health....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us