StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Medical Tests and the Ethical Implications Associated with It - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
This research begins with the statement that Camilla is a 14-year-old teenager, who shouldn’t be forced to go for the test if she doesn’t want to. As responsible citizens, her parents have a moral duty to respect her decision and she has a moral right to decide what’s right for her and what’s not…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Medical Tests and the Ethical Implications Associated with It
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Medical Tests and the Ethical Implications Associated with It"

MEDICAL TESTS – THE ETHICAL IMPLICATIONS ASSOCIATED WITH ITMedical tests- the ethical implications associated with itCamilla is a 14 year old teenager, who shouldn’t be forced to go for the test if she doesn’t want to. As responsible citizens, her parents have a moral duty to respect her decision and she has a moral right to decide what’s right for her and what’s not. However Camilla should realize that even though she doesn’t want to get labeled as a positive hemophilia carrier, she should get herself tested so that she can protect the future of her kids.

The ethical theories that apply in this case are:1. Act utilitarianism2. KantianismAct utilitarianism applies because in this case, Camilla’s act will determine what the future consequences are. According to act utilitarianism it is our duty to act in a way that will produce better consequences. If Camilla decides to get herself tested, then this act of hers will definitely produce better results, mainly in the form of her protecting the future of her kids (Scarre, 1996). Another important point which should be noted here is that, according to act utilitarianism, the correctness of an act should be judged by the consequence.

Thus even if the act of forcing Camilla is wrong on the moral front, the consequence of it is not. If her parents force her to take the test, the good consequence that will come out of it in the form of Camilla taking extra care when planning her kids, will nullify the negativity of the way she was forced to take the test (Smart, 1973). The other ethical principle, which applies in this case in Kantianism. It states that an action, which makes you happy, may not be necessarily morally right or wrong.

Thus we should determine right and wrong internally through autonomy and self law. The individual himself should determine what he wants to do, which is what Camilla should do. According to Kantianism, Camilla should not go and get her tests done just because the consequences of it would be right. But she should get the tests done because it is right to do so. Kantianism is not consequential. Actions depend on a person’s motive and intentions. Camilla does not want to be labeled as a positive hemophilia carrier.

She views this as a negative consequence. However, according to Kantianism, what she should focus on is why she wants to get the test done, not what would be the outcome. She should focus on the fact that if she gets the tests done right now, she will be better prepared to look after her kids later on in life. Thus for the safety and well being of her kids, she should go and get her tests done. However, she should do it only because she thinks its right and not because someone else is forcing her to do so (Wood, 2008).

ConclusionAfter reviewing the ethical dilemma presented in the light of the ethical theories, it can be concluded that Camilla should definitely take the test. However it should be noted that she does it on her own accord, and not because she was forced to do so by her parents. If Camilla doesn’t think it fit that she needs the test, then her parents should respect her decision and not force her to take it. REFERENCES1. Scarre G. (1996), Utilitarianism. Routeledge 2. Smart J. J. C. (1973).

Utilitarianism; for and against. Cambridge University Press3. Wood A. W. (2008). Kantian Ethics. Cambridge University Press

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Medical Tests and the Ethical Implications Associated with It Case Study”, n.d.)
Medical Tests and the Ethical Implications Associated with It Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1740350-case-study-1
(Medical Tests and the Ethical Implications Associated With It Case Study)
Medical Tests and the Ethical Implications Associated With It Case Study. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1740350-case-study-1.
“Medical Tests and the Ethical Implications Associated With It Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1740350-case-study-1.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Medical Tests and the Ethical Implications Associated with It

Health Sciences and Medicine Research Methods

(1) The Declaration of Helsinki is a set of the ethical principles for medical research involving human subjects adopted by the 18th World Medical Association (WMA) general assembly in Helsinki, Finland in June 1964.... e) What is the overall pooled effect and associated 95% confidence interval for the meta-analysis?... This is because of ethical considerations and the protection of the rights of the persons being used in the research being violated....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Ethical Dimensions of Research Studies

Thirdly, it is important for the researchers involved to respect the independence as well as confidentiality of any medical information associated with the test subjects.... the ethical Dimensions of the Biological and Health Sciences.... In these children's case, the researchers did not inform the subjects on the dangers and implications that could follow exposure of secondhand smoke to children.... The parents and… This study went against all ethical standards of research behavior as the lives of children who were the subjects were put in danger. There is a ethical Dimensions of Research Studies ethical dimensions of Research Studies According to Siegel , a research conducted in Naples, Italy focused on 498 School going children who were all white, involved intentionally exposing these children to smoke....
2 Pages (500 words) Term Paper

Jurassic Park by John Crichton

Hammond's system was designed to predict tragedy, just like humans today have the ability to undergo medical tests and know their health status.... The same argument is applicable to contemporary society, which pays less attention to the implications of the ethical aspect associated with technology....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Gestational Diabetes Mellitus

ADA argues that selective screening will help in reducing the costs associated with screening, elimination of inconveniences associated with the process as well as lowering anxiety connected with diabetes.... A number of ethical issues that must be taken into consideration before or during the screening process include how comfortable the patient is during the process, the laboratory costs associated with the screening and other risks factors such as missing the diagnosis after the process has been initiated....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Heart Failure study method

This paper also intends to explain about the ethical considerations that concentrate on whether the patients are protected and the ethical considerations are perfect for the study in Fayazi, Zarea, Abbasi & Ahmadi (2012).... Secondary, but holding considerable significance, the other objective of Fayazi, Zarea, Abbasi & Ahmadi (2012) was to identify problems and the complications associated with the heart failure issue leading to the identification of the significance and implications on the frequency of the issue....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Impact of Non-Compliance with Mandatory Immunizations

However, such overwhelming fete in the world of human medicine has only been made possible through rigorous research, standard tests, and continual improvement of vaccines.... "Impact of Non-Compliance with Mandatory Immunizations" paper supports that people that refuse to immunize their children are putting other children at risk of illness and death....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Health Sciences and Medicine Research Methods

The Declaration of Helsinki is a set of the ethical principles for medical research involving human subjects adopted by the 18th World Medical Association (WMA) general assembly in Helsinki, Finland in June 1964.... This is because of ethical considerations and the protection of the rights of the persons being used in the research being violated.... The Declaration of Geneva of the World medical Association binds the physician with the words, ‘‘The health of my patient will be my first consideration,'' and the International Code of medical Ethics declares that, ‘‘A physician shall act only in the patient's interest when providing medical care which might have the effect of weakening the physical and mental condition of the patient....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Tracking Technology

This essay ''Tracking Technology'' describes the various tracking technologies used to get the location of a person, as well as the ethical considerations of this process.... nbsp;… Total Information Awareness (TIA), a proposal by the Defense Advanced Research projects (DARPA) that is reliant on data mining and tracking information will be discussed in terms of the regulations and ethical concerns involved....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us