StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Evaluation of article from The Economist - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Overall the article “Sooty skies” seems to be a one-off for an acclaimed magazine like The Economist as the article fails to conform to the standards of prose expected from writings in a publication of such repute. However one is able to get the main ideas expressed in the…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.9% of users find it useful
Evaluation of article from The Economist
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Evaluation of article from The Economist"

and number submitted Article Evaluation: “Sooty skies” Overall the article “Sooty skies” seems to be a one-off for an acclaimed magazine like The Economist as the article fails to conform to the standards of prose expected from writings in a publication of such repute. However one is able to get the main ideas expressed in the article after reading it completely. The following paragraphs evaluate some of the writing-related characteristics of the article.Clarity and FlowFirstly, while it is part of a contemporary fashion in the world of article writing, the title of the article offers no insight into the content in the article though it does manage to refer to the focal point of the essay.

The abstract statement (“Sooty skies”, 1) uses technical terms that make it difficult for a novice of the field of aviation to understand, without reading the article, what the article is about. Right at the very start of the article the writer addresses an aspect of de-icing an aeroplane in the first sentence and continues on with it in the third sentence with no regard for the change of perspective in the second sentence. Similarly in the second paragraph, the writer introduces a Dawid Janas with no reference to Dawid’s relevance to the discussion until later on in the article.

Then the article moves on to describe the process of formation of a substance without describing the background of the substance and its relevance to the topic of the article, making it hard for the reader to maintain interest. The writer commits a similar mistake by describing the conductivity of the substance in detail without first stating that conductance of electricity though the substance is a process of the new de-icing technique. This application of the substance becomes clear only later on with an indirect reference to it by the writer as he compares the two substances used in de-icing.

Information and PresentationWhile a lot of information in the article is misleading and some is suspicious, the content does provide the necessary knowledge needed to understand the views expressed and the basics of the technology referred to by the writer. However the article contains engineering jargon that makes the aspect of de-icing techniques covered in the article irrelevant to business course students, though the price and viability comparisons of materials for de-icing in the later paragraphs can be considered relevant to the domain of business management education.

The only image included in the article offers little help in understanding the gist of the article without having read a good part of the written content first. Amusingly enough the second sentence asks the reader to consider the experience of observers rather than the de-icing staff itself to understand the difficulty in de-icing. In the same paragraph the writer makes a reference to ‘the chemicals’ garish colours’ which is not easy for the reader to understand. And in the next paragraph, the presumed connection between freezing of antifreeze chemical and the need for spraying it multiple times is almost impossible to understand without prior technical information of de-icing processes.

While the implication from the use of the term ‘old soot’ in the next paragraph is discernable, the term is not appropriate for how it is used in the article. And while the writer contends that nanotubes are ‘famously’ better conductors than copper, the audience of a business magazine such as The Economist is inclined to disagree with him. In the same paragraph the writer makes a rather astonishing comparison between the thickness of one entity and the length of a similar entity. Also the writer makes all his comparisons and judgements based on the proposals of one university student whose invention has not even been tested.

While most of the information provided is understandable, the writer provides no sources to verify it and the scientific jargon is not of much use or interest to readers of business magazines.Language and GrammarThe writing misses the mark of acceptable grammar use at several locations in the article. The writer’s abrupt departure in the third sentence of the article from the direction of the discourse provides a prime example of improper use of a preposition “It” and is easily identifiable as such.

The writing neglects the target audience by including technical jargon which is not presented in easily understandable English either, to ease comprehension for novices of industrial processes’ information. The style of writing too is neglectful of the reader’s affiliation to the writer and employs informal terms such as ‘a pop’ to discuss sober facts in a business article. The writer makes it clear that the material proposed by Dawid is developed through rigorous mechanical processing; yet the writer keeps referring to the material as a type of soot, which is a by-product of the incomplete burning of carbon.

Even if the material technically qualifies as soot, it is misleading to present it as such.Though the article does seem to provide some value of information, especially if the information provided is correct, it seems to be misplaced with most of the discussion about feasibility relating to industrial processes rather than business matters.References"Sooty Skies." The Economist 2013: n. pag. The Economist. 30 Nov. 2013. Web. 9 Dec. 2013. .

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Evaluation of article from The Economist Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Evaluation of article from The Economist Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1625042-evaluation-of-article-from-the-economist
(Evaluation of Article from The Economist Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Evaluation of Article from The Economist Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/business/1625042-evaluation-of-article-from-the-economist.
“Evaluation of Article from The Economist Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1625042-evaluation-of-article-from-the-economist.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Evaluation of article from The Economist

The Global Financial Crisis in Europe

ccording to an article titled “The fiscal solution” that appeared in the economist on 29thNov 2011 by Buttonwood, the long term solutions to this problem require the assumption of debts of states facing problems by the bloc.... he European debt crisis is the inability of governments within the Euro zone to finance their national debt without aid from the outside....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Job Applicants with English American Names

ta derived from the renowned Professor Marianne Bertrand and Sendhil Mullinathan paper in 2004.... According to the research conducted, the number of female employees with African American names that received a Call _Back were less than the number of men from the same origin.... White American employers would prefer working with persons who are from a white race origin.... uestion hThe employment rate increased progressively from Model 1 to Model 3....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article

How to Reinvent Capitalism and Unleash a Wave of Innovation and Growth by Porter and Kramer

Corporate social responsibility comes after pressure from the government and NGOs where firms use it to increase own reputations while they treat monies used as ordinary expenses.... Summary There is a thin line between the competitiveness of a firm and the health of the society as a firm derives success from the community that purchases its products and provides a supportive environment.... Fairtrade is a good example of social value since it pays poor farmers from its proportion of revenue so that they can achieve a higher output in their activities....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Where Do Poverty and Inequality in the US Overlap by Neil Shah

The article argues that poverty and income inequality are widespread in the southern parts of the United States.... hellip; According to the article, the counties with the highest level of poverty had a Gini coefficient greater than 0.... The article presents two critical components of economic indicators, namely poverty and income inequality.... In this respect, the information contained in the article is relevant in evaluating the relative poverty and prosperity of the United States....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Historical Perspectives on Family Studies by Stephanie Koontz

It initially discussed what other historians learned from the study of families from diverse fields such as sociologists, demographers, and economists.... It initially discussed what other historians learned from the study of families from diverse fields such as sociologists, demographers, and economists.... How does this relate to what you have learned from the textbook or in class?... … The paper "Historical Perspectives on Family Studies by Stephanie Koontz" is a worthy example of an article review on social science....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Screen Time Finds Education Drop-Off

This article "Screen Time Finds Education Drop-Off" discusses if increased screen time was contributing to education in children (Rich 1).... hellip; The article supported the generalization of the study findings over children under the age of 10 and also indicated that the education content in TV shows reduces significantly with an increase in age of the children for whom the programs are designed (Rich 2).... The author of the article appears to be a science reporter of the NY Times instead of any scientific researcher (Rich 1)....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

The Role of Uncertainty of Outcome and Scoring

Through the use of theoretical methods of research- that entailed the authors gathering information from the NFL official website- the authors were able to gather information on the opinions of the fans regarding the players, coaches, and the game itself (215).... nbsp; from the regression results and summary statistics of fan ratings, it is valid to conclude that fan ratings are vital in establishing long-term relationships between sports leagues and their fans (220)....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Here's a Generation Wanting to Be Heard by Merrington

The youth behave the way they do because it is what society has already made them believe that it is what is expected from them.... The essay is based on premises that youths in Australia are not lazy nor they disconnected from social issues.... … The paper "Here's a Generation Wanting to Be Heard by Merrington" is a delightful example of an article on sociology.... The author of the article,” Here's a generation wanting to be heard” argues that youth in Australia are passionate, forward-thinking youngsters who are concerned about social issues and development....
7 Pages (1750 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us